12 of the Best Fireplace Bars, Restaurants, and Cafes

City Guide, Food & Drink


Written by Emily Morrow

Published on January 8, 2015


Now that the weather is a bit more wintry, we figured you could use some extra motivation to step out. Sadly good eats and strong drinks can only motivate to a certain extent. So in the interest of proving there’s more to life than sunny days and day drinking in beer gardens (although not much more if you ask us), we put together a list of some of the best spots to cozy up next to a roaring fire – including coffee shops, classy restaurants, a few drinking spots of course, and everything in-between.


Hamburg Brewing Co. Fireplace

Photo courtesy of Hamburg Brewing Co.

Hamburg Brewing Co.

Neighborhood: Hamburg

If you’re looking to drink near a fireplace in Western New York you absolutely cannot beat the tasting room at Hamburg Brewing Company. With cushions, benches, and tables surrounding the fire there’s not a bad seat in the house. The list of impressive Hamburg brews and light fare is enough to satisfy pretty much any age group. Trust us, people come from all over to experience the “are we in Buffalo?” effect on the outskirts of Hamburg.

More Info


D'Arcy McGees Fireplace

Photo courtesy of D’Arcy McGees

D’Arcy McGees

Neighborhood: Downtown

If you find yourself seeking warmth in the Theater District or craving an Irish pub experience, D’Arcy McGees is right up your ally. Grab a few imported beers, maybe a Shepard’s Pie, and head to the stools and small tables by one of two fireplaces.

More Info


Armor Inn Tap Room

Photo courtesy of Armor Inn Tap Room

Armor Inn Tap Room

Neighborhood: Hamburg

Technically this isn’t a fireplace, but there is definitely fire involved at this suburban tap room. The Armor Inn in Hamburg has a couple fire pits outside on their patio – perfect for a nice change of pace after being cooped up inside crowded bars all winter long. Maybe save this one for a night when it’s above 15 degrees.

More Info


The Lodge

Photo courtesy of The Lodge

The Lodge Bar + Grill

Neighborhood: Downtown

Come for the restaurant/bar’s sophisticated atmosphere and fabulous decor, stay for the yummy cocktails by the fire right in the dead center of the city. Easy access to the Chip Strip, Theater District, hotels, and more.

More Info


Merge Fireplace

Photo courtesy of Merge


Neighborhood: Downtown

Cozy up by the Merge fireplace with a crisp cocktail and a warm cup of soup while catching a live performance – usually jazz. Good for before or after diner. Merge has a great selection of vegetarian friendly dishes but plenty for the carnivore too.

More Info / SOB’s Recommendation


Spot Coffee Fireplace

Photo courtesy of Spot Coffee OP

Spot Coffee OP

Neighborhood: Village of Orchard Park

If you’re in the mood for a fireside coffee and a snack, you can’t beat this adorable fireplace setup at SPoT Coffee in the Village of Orchard Park. Bring a friend or a good book, grab a breakfast sandwich and a latte, and stay all day.

More Info



Neighborhood: Downtown

Encore has five fireplaces in that old, unique building of theirs. One is in the bar area, one is upstairs near a couple of tables near the sushi station, and the rest are scattered about just waiting for you to come get toasty. We’d be crazy if we didn’t mention our favorite day of the week to stop by Encore – Tuesday’s All You Can Eat Sushi.

More Info / SOB’s Recommendation


Pan American Grill Fireplace

Photo courtesy of Pan American Grill & Brewery

Pan American Grill and Brewery @ Hotel Lafayette

Neighborhood: Downtown

Is there anything better than a stoic leather couch by a hearty fire? Yes; a stoic leather couch by a hearty fire with a beverage in hand. Lounge by the fire at Pan American Grill before or after dining at one of the Hotel Lafayette’s several delicious restaurants including the Pan Am Grill itself, Bourbon and Butter or Butterwood Sweet & Savory. We’re pretty positive this fireplace setup with both surprise and impress you.

More Info


Gabriel's Gate Fireplace

Photo by @hughes13 via Instagram

Gabriel’s Gate

Neighborhood: Downtown

While the ambiance at Gabriel’s Gate is more of an Allentown “dive bar” than others on this list, it’s hands down one of the favorite spots to get wings in Buffalo – and for good reason. Tell your waitress you want a “single medium”, then just sit back by the fire with a cold one and let them do the rest.

More Info


The Roycroft Inn Fireplace

Photo courtesy of The Roycroft

The Roycroft Inn

Neighborhood: East Aurora

Outstanding Brunch. Historic Buildings. Artisanal Menu. Seasonal ingredients. While The Roycroft is a favorite in the summertime thanks to their upscale brunch on the patio, it also serves as a perfect place to escape the cold for a hearty, fireside meal in the adorable Village of East Aurora. Dine by the fire or drink fireside in the newly renovated Craftsman Lounge.

SOB’s Recommendation


Resurgence Brewing Co. Fire Pit

Resurgence Brewing Co.

Resurgence Brewing Co.

Neighborhood: West Side

The “fireplace” at Resurgence Brewing Co. is again, actually a fire pit. It makes for a great opportunity to warm up on a chilly night all year round, but especially in the winter. Stop by to witness a part of Buffalo’s resurgence first hand, try a Sponge Candy Stout, or play one of their fun giant games.

More Info


Daily Planet Coffee

Photo by Jill Greenberg

The Daily Planet Coffee Co.

Neighborhood: Hertel

This new coffee shop in North Buffalo is equipped with everything you need to get through the winter. That is plenty of fireside tables, coffee, live music of all kinds, poetry, fresh scones made in house, seasonal drinks, and our favorite – board games.

More Info

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Emily Morrow</a>

Written by Emily Morrow

Emily is co-founder and Director of Storytelling at Step Out Buffalo. Her favorite things to do are eat, travel, and think up business ideas. Emily is originally from Hamburg, NY and her out of town friends will tell you that she loves to talk about Buffalo any chance she gets.

Supporting WNY's Black Community

In the wake of the horrific, racism-fueled attack on WNY's Black community on May 14, Step Out Buffalo is committed to sharing content that supports our Black neighbors and provides valuable resources for those looking for ways to help during this heartbreaking time and beyond.


Forgotten Password?

You must be logged in to use this feature.