4 Reasons You Should Absolutely Put Garage Cafe on Your Radar ASAP

Food & Drink


Written by SOB Creative

Published on July 24, 2018

Turkey Bacon Wrap / Photo courtesy of Garage Cafe

Updated August 2018

Transitioning from auto shop to restaurant is not your average business plan, but it made a whole lot of sense to this local couple. Owners Joe and Lisa of Garage Cafe & Lounge have lived and loved in the North Buffalo community for years, 42 to be exact. A series of unfortunate events led them to close the doors at J&L Auto Repair, but their story doesn’t end there.



Sweet Sauce Meatballs / Photo courtesy of Garage Cafe

Refurbishing the space gave this hometown couple a new opportunity, and the new concept is a welcomed addition to Hertel Avenue. This refurb was quite the project, but boy it was well worth the wait.

Here are four reasons why you’ll want to introduce yourself to The Garage Cafe, and thank us later.


Cinnamon Buns / Photo courtesy of Garage Cafe

1. The Sweets

The buzz about these cinnamon rolls started months ago, and people are still talking about them. Rumor has it these sought-after sweets are the best in Buffalo. A large batch takes 4+ hours to make, so they are only available on Saturdays and Sundays for now.  We hear repeat customers show up every weekend at 8 a.m. to get their fix. Heads up: be prepared to get hooked.


[mc4wp_form id=”238972″]


The Ferarri / Photo courtesy of Garage Cafe

Italian Cookies / Photo courtesy of Garage Cafe

2. The Bites

The deliciousness is plentiful on the main menu too. The stacked sandwiches are a customer favorite, especially The Ferrari and The Cadillac paninis. Yes, these sandwiches are named after cars in homage to J&L. The menu is continuing to grow thanks to requests from customers. If you are all about the small plate life, you’re in luck. They have buckets of meatballs, flatbread pizzas, giant pretzels, charcuterie plates, and more.


3. ‘The Wrecking Yard’ – AKA The Beer Garden

Backyard. Beer Garden. YASSS! ‘The Wrecking Yard’ officially opened the *largest* beer garden on Hertel on August 4th. This huge outdoor space is a win for the entire street. 


Photo x Step Out Buffalo



4. The Live Music

Live music has arrived on Hertel Avenue. Check out bands every Friday night & starting August 8th at their Bike Night on Wednesdays.

We love us a local story, especially this one, so join us in welcoming them to the North Buffalo neighborhood by stopping in for some sweet and savory local eats.


The Garage Cafe

1127 Hertel Ave., Buffalo


Written by <a href="" target="_self">SOB Creative</a>

Written by SOB Creative

Find More ➭ Sponsored Content

Enter your email to get The Insider Hit List - a timely short list of restaurants, things to do and more recommended by the Step Out Buffalo staff.


Forgotten Password?

You must be logged in to use this feature.