Have you ever had a reuben? Typically popular around St. Patrick’s Day, the reuben is a sandwich composed of corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing, grilled between two slices of rye bread. If you’re looking to get your hands on one of these creations, you’ve come to the right place.
To aid in your search for the best reubens in Western New York and/or your neighborhood, we polled our social media followers to bring you a list of the best around town. Pro-tip: save this post for future reference.
Let’s get into the guide – in order to pull the following list together, we asked our Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram followers where to find the best reuben in Buffalo and WNY. They answered with their top picks and we’ve included the full list of reader recommendations below. If it was mentioned, it’s listed below.
Because we received hundreds of comments resulting in tons of recommendations, there are options all across WNY, all worth recommending according to Western New Yorkers.
While many recommendations were mentioned more than once, there were certain places mentioned over and over (and over) again. It’s safe to say these are our readers’ top picks for reubens in Buffalo & WNY – in order! Keep scrolling for the full list of mentions.
Nestled in a small town along the Erie Canal, we offer a breakfast and full lunch menu, as wells as a full coffee and espresso menu with smoothies, frappes, ...
155, Chandler Street Buffalo, New York 14207 • $$$$$
North Buffalo
Since 2015 Barrel + Brine has given new life to an old tradition by using old world fermentation and pickling techniques passed down through generations. ...
Big Ditch Brewing Co. is one of Downtown Buffalo's shinning stars when it comes to brewery/restaurant combos. The tap room is huge, yet welcoming and does ...
2134 Seneca Street South Buffalo, New York 14220 • $$$$$
South Buffalo
Blackthorn Restaurant $ Pub is the quintessential cozy, no pretense South Buffalo joint that has been serving this neighborhood for decades. They offer ...
Bravo Cafe $ Catering opened its doors in February 2004. Its original location was a small, ten table cafe. In October 2006, we relocated just down the ...
6861 Main St. Williamsville, New York 14221 • $$$$$
North Towns
At Buffalo Brewpub we brew our own beers! New York State's Oldest Brew Pub dedicated to Fine Beer, food, and fun! Renowned for its fabulous beer and savory ...
The Buffalo Irish Center is much more than a meeting place in a pub, a bingo hall, or an establishment for little girls to learn dancing. Since 1970, the ...
Buffalo RiverWorks is the city's premier riverfront, boating, sports, music and entertainment destination located along the banks of the Buffalo River.
The ...
2945 Southwestern Blvd Orchard Park, New York 14127 • $$$$$
South Towns
Whether you're out for dinner with the family or for drinks with friends, the BSG delivers a great time. With 21 TV's, we're the obvious choice to catch ...
3700 Southwestern Blvd. Orchard Park, New York 14127 • $$$$$
South Towns
Full service restaurant open 7 days a week for lunch and dinner.
Buffalo's Best Grill Is Open 7 Days A Week Serving Lunch and Dinner; Sundays - Brunch ...
Cafe 59 offers fair-trade, gourmet coffee, espresso, and a variety of other hot and cold drinks. Our menu of freshly made soups, salads and sandwiches ...
Casey's is the type of place where you can get good reliable bar food, and inexpensive drinks. They have a great fish fry on weekends, a spaghetti dinner ...
'This is a family tradition that started 63 years ago. My grandfather started with a simple vision; to create a place that feels like home, provides friendly ...
Clarksburg is for hard cider drinkers who don’t take themselves too seriously. Whether you enjoy foraging for wild edibles, or your roof rack just came ...
SOB Says: One of Buffalo's favorite taverns, Cole's has some of the best wings in town and always serves up a great selection of local craft beers.
Along ...
4348 Seneca St West Seneca, New York 14224 • $$$$$
South Towns
Since it opened its doors in 2011, the Ebenezer Ale House has been providing Western New York with one of the best selections of food and drink in the ...
530 Rhode Island St Buffalo, New York 14213 • $$$$$
Buffalo
SOB Says: The Essex Street Pub is a fantastic little hidden gem on the edge of the west side. Full of charm and perfect for lunch, dinner or late night ...
5 E Washington Street Ellicottville, New York 14731 • $$$$$
Southern Tier
With the atmosphere and flavors of a traditional Irish Pub, Finnerty's Tap Room in Ellicottville, NY brings unique entertainment, worldly pub food, and ...
The Flip Side offers a unique and friendly environment - it’s a great place to meet and eat with friends! We are currently offering a full menu, featuring ...
A Word from Gabriel's Gate
Located in the heart of Allentown, Gabriel's Gate is one of the original Tift Row Houses, which were built in 1864. We offer ...
Under the ownership of a team of local craft beer enthusiasts, the long time bar now features a brewery next door, which provides locally brewed beer to ...
405 S Cascade Dr Springville, New York 14141 • $$$$$
South Towns
JD's Brew Pub is locally owned by the Morlok brothers, Jeff and Dan. They opened the doors to the pub in 2016 with one goal in mind, to bring craft beers, ...
Joe's Deli, located in the heart of the Hertel Ave strip, features tempting home made soups, salads, wraps and specialty sandwiches in a clean, inviting ...
Joey's Place is expanding at our new location!
Joey's is still serving delicious homemade meatloaf, mashed potatoes, lasagna, beef on weck and more. ...
Jonny C's NY Deli and Caterers is owned by Jon Cohen,ï¾ a native of the New York City area whoï¾ has owned and operated numerous delis and restaurants. ...
Great Reubens and much more JP Fitzgerald s is the Southtowns hottest spot for casual fun with family and friends. From "The Best Reuben Sandwich in WNY" ...
Broadway themed Sandwich Shop, Cafe $ Catering Company located in the Village of Lancaster, NY. We have an extensive sandwich and salad menu along with ...
Lebro s dishes are served to satisfy. That means we don t skimp on the preparation or the delicious ingredients that ensure your order tastes even better ...
878 Cleveland Dr Cheektowaga, New York 14225 • $$$$$
Cheektowaga and East
The Lunetta Family has been serving the Buffalo, NY community for over 55 years. We have earned a reputation for delicious home style Italian and American ...
This is quality, 'honest' food served in a pleasant, casual atmosphere. The concise menu covers all the right bases and preparation is unpretentious. The ...
Cleverly laying the movie Mob shtick on thick, Marco's Italian Deli is where appetizers are served family-style and sandwiches are called 'sangwiches,' ...
'In 1988, Marco Sciortino purchased the building from Andy and Joe Darone. Since then, Marco has been the owner and chef of Marco s Restaurant, and has ...
The history of Mitchells dates back to the 1940's. James Mitchell purchased the property for the Mitchell Family returning home from WW2. The original ...
Mooney's Sports Bar $ Grill was started with two things in mind; families having a fun dining experience and giving our customers top quality food in HUGE ...
Come check out our brand new location on Broadway in Depew! Mooney's was put together with one thing in mind - having a good time. When you come here, ...
Mooney's was put together with one thing in mind - having a good time. When you come here, you can expect good drinks, an awesome menu, and good times. ...
Site says: Mooney's was put together with one thing in mind - having a good time. When you come here, you can expect good drinks, an awesome menu, and ...
11 Bloomfield Avenue South Buffalo, New York 14220 • $$$$$
South Buffalo
SOB Says about Nine-Eleven Tavern: Between the mind-blowing flavors and the not mind-blowing prices you really can't go wrong here. Plus, this place has ...
3864 Abbott Rd Orchard Park, New York 14127 • $$$$$
South Towns
Neighborhood Pub with great homemade American fare, over 50 wing flavors, house cooked turkey, beef corned beef and so much more.. Along with great breakfast ...
Located in Lancaster, Olive Tree Family Restaurant is renowned for serving breakfast all day, everyday, its mouthwatering meals and its true family atmosphere. ...
Serving BBQ favorites such as BBQ Pulled Pork, Texas-style Beef Brisket, St. Louis-cut Pork Ribs and BBQ Chicken. Bar-B-Q is cooked without sauce, we use ...
Pearl Street Grill $ Brew Pub is the second largest brew pub in America.Premier spot downtown for pre/post Sabres, Bison or Bandits games, any First Niagara, ...
3670 McKinley Pkwy Buffalo, New York 14219 • $$$$$
South Towns
Since 2000 identical twins Sherry and Shelly Biscaro with longtime friend Marina Ciesla have been cooking up some delicious food at the Poppyseed Restaurant. ...
SOB Says: Potter's Field Restaurant $ Pub is an eye-catching neighborhood tavern on Potters Rd. in West Seneca. The menu is surprisingly hefty based on ...
A Word From Risa's
My bubbie and zaida (Rose and Frank Sandler) started our first restaurant in downtown Buffalo over 50 years ago. From there my mother ...
4179 Lake Shore Rd Hamburg, New York 14075 • $$$$$
South Towns
Established 1985, Rodneys has consistently remained the restaurant of choice for area diners in search of quality food and service at resonable prices.
With ...
This WNY landmark is on everyone's must stop if you are passing through town. A top Beef on Week mainstay, with the prerequisite carving station, this ...
3480 Millersport Hwy Getville, New York 14068 • $$$$$
North Towns
Originally the premises was called The Pine Lodge, noted for the pine trees in front of the building. Purchased by Richard and Carol Lillis in 1966 who ...
The Shamus Restaurant is located in Historic Lockport, NY. We are known for great food, friendly hospitality, excellent service and a pleasant dining atmosphere. ...
Founded in Syracuse, NY, Strong Hearts is a fast-casual eatery leading the way in vegan comfort food style dining since 2008. Available all day, every ...
Traditional Irish Pub and Restaurant in the heart of Buffalo's theater district.
Serving traditional Irish food and supporting Irish culture
Read Our ...
4190 N Buffalo Rd Orchard Park, New York 14127 • $$$$$
South Towns
A Word from The Byrd House
Orchard Park, New York's best bar. Casual Pub atmosphere. Flat Screen TV's, 18 draft beers to choose from. Great food and ...
3410 Delaware Ave Tonawanda, New York 14217 • $$$$$
North Buffalo
SOB Says: I'm going to begin this section with one word: go. I'll be honest in saying that The Delaware wasn't even on my radar until one day when we found ...
The Globe Market is located at 762 Elmwood Ave in the heart of the Elmwood village. It opened in 2003 and is owned and operated by Alice Eoannou. The concept ...
529 Englewood Avenue Buffalo, New York 14223 • $$$$$
North Towns
Established in 2013, The Howling Rooster features casual American dining in a comfortable and relaxed atmosphere.
A private banquet room, accommodating ...
6261 Transit Rd East Amherst, New York 14051 • $$$$$
North Towns
'Best Char-Broiled Burger in WNY' - The Buffalo Spree. Featuring great food at an affordable price. Family owned and operated. Rock offers a wide variety ...
Welcome to 'The Goat' as we are affectionately called. A place where we build the best burger you've ever had, serve award-winning Berbere wings and thin ...
4869 Southwestern Blvd Hamburg, New York 14075 • $$$$$
South Towns
Some unique features of Uncle Joe's that keep our regulars coming back, and turn visitors into regulars after just one visit are: Fresh-cut french fries, ...
Buffalo's Premier Sports Bar $ Eatery. Join us for cold drink, exceptional food, friendly fans $ fun for all KeyBank Center, Coca-Cola Field $ Canalside ...
641 Oakwood Ave East Aurora, New York 14052 • $$$$$
South Towns
A family restaurant open for lunch to late night dining. Also a full bar area containing many tvs and daily bar specials. Locals say good for wings, burgers ...
If You're Looking For A Good Home Cooked Meal, Wayside Family Restaurant Is The Place To Visit. Our Wide Variety Of Menu Items Includes Breakfast Plates, ...
1541 Hertel Avenue Buffalo, New York 14216 • $$$$$
North Buffalo
For the last 20 years the Wellington Pub has provided families $ friends with the highest quality food and beverage and with terrific service in a friendly ...
One crazy idea. Two brothers and their wives. One old cold storage building in a historic town. And a lot of good beer. This pretty much sums up who we ...
Niagara Falls Blvd North Tonawanda,, New York 14120 • $$$$$
Niagara County
One crazy idea. Two brothers and their awesome wives. Two old, kick-ass locations. A cold storage building and a music factory in historic towns AND A ...
ZJ's Family Restaurant in Hamburg brings the best elements of a classic Americana diner to the forefront: Delicious home-cooked recipes, affordable prices ...
Our new design features a better browsing experience, modern mobile navigation, more visual displays of key info, better filtering options on the search page, and much more.
We hope you love our new look! That said, we’re #ForeverTweaking and would greatly appreciate your feedback so we can make StepOutBuffalo.com *all* you want and need as your go-to resource for the best of Western New York!
