Buffalo Pop-up The Crucible is Kicking Ass & Taking Names

Food & Drink


Written by Brett Llenos Smith

Published on March 20, 2017

When the chef at one of the hottest restaurants in town calls a certain dish the “best thing he’s eaten all year,” Western New York gastronauts should sit up and take notice.
The chef in question is Mike Dimmer, from Marble + Rye, and the dish being given ‘Best of’ status was the Goat en Crepinette with daikon butter from The Crucible, a culinary pop-up from two local chefs and a local sommelier.
Described as a “trial by fire” on their Facebook page, The Crucible are at it again, with another pop-up event slated to happen Monday, April 3.
In a recent conversation over coffee and scones, the Crucible’s chefs, Manuel Ocasio and David Roque, told me the menus for their rave-reviewed events, as impressive as they turn out to be, are actually done by the seat of their pants – with the dishes cooked for the first time on the day of the event.

“Cooking has so much to do with technique and being comfortable with ingredients,” Roque said, trying to explain how his team always seems to make their dishes click at the last minute.
“Like when you make something in your house, and it’s a kind of patchwork recipe,” he continued. “I think that if you have a certain level of intuition, technique, and skill, you should feel comfortable putting something together in your brain, putting it on paper and saying, ‘Alright, we can do this.’
“There’s a lot of tweaking that happens, but that happens on a daily basis in every kitchen, like if a recipe calls for ‘juice of two lemons’ and one lemon has a ton of juice,” Roque added. “You know things can vary and you’re always going to have those moments. So long as you have some technique and an idea in place for how something is going to go down, you just make it happen.”

The culinary duo behind The Crucible admitted that there have been a few times when a dish didn’t coalesce as planned. When this has happened, the approach has been to tweak it as best they can, cross their fingers, and serve it to their guests with a side of self-assurance.
“For this one salad, we did a beet and buttermilk emulsion, which I don’t even know how that idea came, but, uh, it was super weird,” Ocasio admitted. “I didn’t know if it was going to be good, but it was already on the menu. We just rolled with it, and the guests were like, ‘That salad was awesome!’
“There are moments like that sometimes,” Roque chimed in. “It’s almost become like a mantra: ‘Hail Mary, there’s one around every corner.’
“That doesn’t necessarily speak for how confident we are in the menu, or our own abilities – but to whether or not the guest is going to receive it: 1) the way that you’ve envisioned it, and 2) the way that you’ve executed it.”
Roque and Ocasio assured me that guests to The Crucible aren’t signing up to be culinary guinea pigs. With tickets to the upcoming Crucible IV running at a cool $100, the duo said they understand both the financial and time commitments that people are making in order to sit down at their tables.

“It’s a lot for anybody to commit to,” Roque said. “You’re not only paying for a tasting menu from people who you don’t really know all that well, if at all, you’re sitting down for two hours, or two-and-a-half hours. That’s your time.
“With that in mind, we’re always streamlining the process and making it more accessible,” he said.
Crucible IV will be the second consecutive event the team has held at The Black Sheep, which should be seen as a tacit endorsement by the chefs behind the nationally-recognized restaurant. Crucible events are also billed as culinary conversations, and with these events held on Mondays, you should expect to see a lot of the top area chefs coming out to this one, potentially to hash out and forge the next wave of ideas to hit Western New York’s most interesting menus.
For more info on The Crucible pop-up and to hear about upcoming dinners, check out their Facebook and Instagram accounts. For tickets to their next dinner on April 3, go to Also, check out a recent review of The Cruicible via Buffalo Spree here.

The Crucible IV

Where: The Black Sheep, 367 Connecticut Street, Buffalo, NY 14213
When: Mon, April 3, 2017
6:30 PM – 9:30 PM 
Cost: $100

We launched a new look!

Our new design features a better browsing experience, modern mobile navigation, more visual displays of key info, better filtering options on the search page, and much more.

We hope you love our new look! That said, we’re #ForeverTweaking and would greatly appreciate your feedback so we can make *all* you want and need as your go-to resource for the best of Western New York!

Send feedback >

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Brett Llenos Smith</a>

Written by Brett Llenos Smith

Brett Llenos Smith is a freelance writer based in Buffalo’s Allentown neighborhood who has been covering local food and culture for Step Out Buffalo over the past six years. As someone with a multi-ethnic background, he has a passion for exploring and understand the many diverse corners of Western New York.
Find More ➭


Forgotten Password?

To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
You must be logged in to use this feature.