Reopened and redesigned after a fire in the winter of 2018.
John and Marys Pizza has been a buffalo tradition since 1952, serving up the best pizza subs and wings made from quality ingredients. Hamburg owners Paul and Sharon Raymond take pride in keeping the integrity that John and Mary Guida established more than 60 years ago.
From hoagies, wraps and subs, to traditional pizza and wings John and Mary’s menu is packed with old-time favorites, and a few modern twists on classic recipes. You can cool down with Perry’s Ice Cream or warm up with a cup of homemade soup. If you’re not in the mood for pizza and wings, no worries we have plenty of others options. From seafood platters to burritos there’s something for everyone at the table.