Where to Get a Great Reuben Sandwich in WNY

Breuben at Big Ditch
Breuben at Big Ditch / Photo courtesy of Big Ditch Brewing Co.

 

Updated February 2020

St. Patrick’s Day calls for one of our favorite Irish classics, and we’re not talking about corned beef and cabbage this time. We’re talking about the ~*reuben*~ sandwich. Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and Russian dressing grilled between two rye toasts…a remarkable coalescence if you ask us. Lucky for you, we’ve rounded up some of the best reubens around town! Here are some of our faves:

Advertisement

Blackthorn Restaurant and Pub
Reuben at The Blackthorn / Photo x Step Out Buffalo

1. The Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub

WEBSITE

2134 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14210

This South Buffalo pub has got one heck of a reuben loaded with meat, sauerkraut and melty swiss cheese- all between *Costanzo’s rye (only the best). You can also expect a side of their famous house-made spicy jalapeño cheddar tater tots, which are TO DIE FOR. And if your friends aren’t into the whole reuben thing, there are plenty of other Irish classics on the menu to get in the St. Patty’s mood.

 

2. Gene McCarthy’s

WEBSITE

73 Hamburg St, Buffalo, NY 14204

We all know that this Old First Ward bar has got some of the best food (and beer) around, but did you know that they make a mean reuben sandwich? Yeah, that’s right- one of the best (and cheapest!) around! *Pro-tip: if you’re looking to take your reuben experience to a whole other level, try the reuben with half corned beef, half turkey– just do it.

 

Breuben at Big Ditch / Photo courtesy of Big Ditch Brewing Co.

3. Big Ditch Brewing Company

WEBSITE

55 E Huron St, Buffalo, NY 14203

Beer isn’t the only thing brewing at Big Ditch. Word on the street says they’ve got a crazy good version of a reuben. It’s called a breuben, aka corned beef brined in Excavator rye brown ale for the most flavorful meat, with the usual reuben works. It’s truly something special, if you ask us.

 

4. Sue’s NY Deli

WEBSITE

622 Main St Buffalo, NY 10044 & 130 S. Elmwood Ave. Buffalo, NY 14202

If you’re looking for an inexpensive lunch-time reuben, we highly recommend stopping by Sue’s. The corned beef is seasoned to perfection, and the fresh rye is toasted just enough! Some even say it’s the best one in town! P.S. they also deliver.

Advertisement

5. Wellington Pub

WEBSITE

1541 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

This cozy Hertel pub has a pretty extensive menu, and it’s easy to miss the reuben- but it is certainly on there, folks. And there’s no better time than now to give it a shot, rather than getting your usual fish fry or wing order.

 

6. JP Fitzgerald’s

WEBSITE

4236 Clark Street, Hamburg, NY 14075

It’s no surprise they made the list… I mean they pretty much have to have a decent reuben, right? But wait. Did you know they have 6 different kinds?! There’s the reuben wrap, the reuben flatbread, the reuben burger, the reuben quesadilla, the open reuben sandwich, and the closed reuben sandwich…There’s a mouthful for ya.

 

Reuben at Joe’s Deli / Photo courtesy of Joe’s Deli

7. Joe’s Deli

WEBSITE

1332 Hertel Ave Buffalo,  714 Maple Rd. Williamsville, 818 Ellicott St. (inside Oishei Children’s Hospital)

When you’re called Joe’s Deli, you gotta sell a good reuben. Joe’s reuben has a special homemade Russian dressing to give this reuben that extra touch.

 

8. Brawler’s Deli

WEBSITE

76 Pearl St, Buffalo, NY 14202

Brawler’s has two options when it comes to the size of their corned beef goodness. For a lighter fare, get the girlie, for the big eaters get the full on brawler.

Advertisement

9. Swan Street Diner

WEBSITE

700 Swan St, Buffalo, NY 14210

Swan Street has that old diner feel which means we can only expect shakes, burgers, and all kinds of sandwich vibes. Their reuben being one of their variety of sandwiches, is made with house corned beef and thousand islands dressing.

 

Cole's
Cole’s reuben / Photo courtesy of Cole’s

10. Cole’s

WEBSITE

1104 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

While the traditional reuben is made with corned beef, Cole’s is offering a version where the choice of turkey is also optional as a corned beef substitute.

 

11. Pano’s

WEBSITE

1081 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

Pano’s may be known for its Greek cuisine but, it also makes a great reuben with the choice of corned beef or turkey.

Advertisement

12. Gabriel’s Gate

WEBSITE

145 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201

If you’ve been to Gabriel’s Gate before, then you know they are capable of making some insanely good dishes. Yes their wings are pretty fantastic but they also make a pretty good reuben.

 

lake effect diner
Reuben at Lake Effect Diner / Photo courtesy of Lake Effect Diner

13. Lake Effect Diner

WEBSITE

3165 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14214

Lake Effect Diner’s reuben is considered a specialty sandwich, so it’s gotta be good. Get it in the traditional form with corned beef or get the rachel with turkey, either choice comes with fresh cut fries and a dill pickle.

 

14. Bertha’s Diner

WEBSITE

1430 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

For an easy lunch destination, Bertha’s is the place to go. Get a traditional reuben with a side of pickle and chips for only $7.75!

Advertisement

eddie brady's
Reuben at Eddie Brady’s / Photo courtesy of Eddie Brady’s

15. Eddie Brady’s

WEBSITE

97 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14203

Salads, sandwiches, and wraps pretty much sums up the vibe of Eddie Brady’s and we couldn’t be happier about it. Stop by for their reuben which consists of corned beef, sour kraut, thousand islands dressing, and Swiss cheese, all melted to perfection on grilled rye bread.

 

16. Pearl Street Grill & Brewery

WEBSITE

76 Pearl St, Buffalo, NY 14202

Headed downtown for a good drink and food? Stop by Pearl Street and grab a reuben which they serve on toasted marble and rye with a side of their homemade chips.

 

17. Power City Eatery

WEBSITE

444 3rd St, Niagara Falls, NY 14301

On their house made Caraway rye, Power City Eatery makes a mean reuben.

 

Honorable Mentions From Our Readers:

One Eyed Jacks: 5983 S Transit Rd, Lockport, NY 14094

Jonny C’s: 9350 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051

Family Tree: 4346 Bailey Ave, Amherst, NY 14226

Mandy’s Cafe: 3796 Clinton St, Buffalo, NY 14224

Ebenezer Ale House: 4348 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224

The Yelling Goat: 205 Central Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

Imperial Pizza: 1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220

The Pub – Wegmans: 8270 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221

Sidelines: 189 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14202

Buffalo Brew Pub: 6861 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221

The Poppyseed: 3670 McKinley Pkwy # 23, Buffalo, NY 14219

Jimmy J’s Pub & Grub: 126 Wheatfield St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120

Forty Thieves: 727 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

Connor’s Restaurant: 3465 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224

Joey’s Place: 1122 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

Mason’s Grille 52: 52 E Main St, Hamburg, NY 14075

Eden Pub: 8557 N Main St, Eden, NY 14057

Carson’s Deli and bakery: Old Saunders Settlement Rd, Lockport, NY 14094

Dwyer’s: 65 Webster St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120

O’Lacys: 5 School St, Batavia, NY 14020

Colden Country Inn: 8815 State Rd, Colden, NY 14033

Lancaster’s Broadway Deli: 5430 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

kelsie.engert
Author: kelsie.engert

Tags from the story
Seasonal Step Out College
Written By
More from kelsie.engert

6 of The Craziest Bloody Marys You’ll Find in WNY

There are some wildly outrageous bloodies that live right here in the...
Read More

3 Comments

Leave a Reply