Guide to Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches in WNY

Photo courtesy of Nickel City Vice

Updated May, 2020

Nothing says summertime more than a good ol’ ice cream sandwich. That perfect blend of cookie to ice cream ratio is something we have a major sweet tooth for this year. And we feel blessed that these places around WNY are upping the bar by making homemade ice cream sandwiches, bringing all the extra goodness that come with that homemade touch. To fulfill your ice cream sandwich dreams, here are all the places to find these heavenly creations!


Nickel City Vice
Coffee ice cream sandwiched between two double chocolate chunk cookies / Photo courtesy of Nickel City Vice

1. Nickel City Vice


New to Buffalo, Nickel City Vice is a pop up specializing in gourmet ice cream sandwiches – and the inspiration for this post. As of now, they have 5 options of sandwiches to choose from. Check out their facebook for updates about where they are popping up in the area!

Breadhive Ice Cream Sandwich / Photo courtesy of the Breadhive Bakery & Cafe

2. Breadhive Bakery & Cafe

402 Connecticut St Buffalo, NY


Brand new to the bakery, these whopping sandwiches are stuffed with ice cream filling surrounded by crunchy cookie goodness.


3. The Sweet Hearth


The Sweet Hearth is a mobile bakery (a.k.a food truck) that features old fashioned baked goods and desserts. You can choose from a few options of homemade cookies to build your own ice cream sandwich. The truck appears at Food Truck Tuesdays in Larkin Square frequently, so keep your eye out to get your hands on one of these sammies!


Candy Cane Ice Cream Sandwich / Photo courtesy of Lake Effect Ice Cream

4. Lake Effect Ice Cream

79 Canal St, Lockport, NY 14094 / 1900 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14214


Lake Effect is always busting out some crazy creations. Stop in to see what assortment of flavors they have for the Summer!


5. Ballyhoo

211 S Park Ave Buffalo, NY


Keeping it classy. Ballyhoo offers a traditional chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich. Because if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.


Platter’s chocolate candy pieces ice cream sandwich / photo courtesy of Platter’s Chocolates

6. Platter’s Chocolates

908 Niagara Falls Blvd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120


One of WNY’s oldest candy stores, Platter’s is no amateur when it comes to all things chocolate and they sure aren’t afraid to apply this to their homemade ice cream sandwiches. They’re known for their special orange chocolate, so we recommend trying out their orange chocolate ice cream sandwich.


Main Street Ice Cream Sandwich / Photo courtesy of Main Street Ice Cream

7. Main Street Ice Cream

35 Main St A, Hamburg, NY 14075


Pictured is one of the ice cream sandwiches they served at the BurgerFest. This Hamburg ice cream shop knows how to make a loaded ice cream sandwich and we are here for it.


Churn’s Garbage Sandwich / Photo courtesy of Churn Soft Serve

8. Churn Soft Serve

1501 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216


Specializing in soft serve ice cream, Churn’s ice cream sandwiches offer the perfect blend of smooth ice cream with the crunch of a crisp cookie and side toppings.


Amsdell Ice Cream Sandwiches / Photo courtesy of Amsdell Ice Cream

9. Amsdell Ice Cream

3041 Amsdell Rd, Hamburg, NY 14075


There are so many options of ice cream sandwiches to choose from at Amsdell Ice cream, and we’re not mad about it.


Kone King East Chipwiches / Photo courtesy of Kone King East

10. Kone King East

117 Hamburg St, East Aurora, NY 14052


These “Chipwiches” are a chocolate chip cookie sandwich loaded with extra chocolate chips and filled with vanilla custard. You’ll find these at Kone King East as well as many other options.


Pumpkin Custard Sandwiches / Photo courtesy of 2 Scoops Ice Cream

11. 2 Scoops Ice Cream

4626 Camp Rd, Hamburg, NY 14075


2 Scoops Ice Cream makes ice cream sandwiches with all kinds of flavored custard from pumpkin and cinnamon to mint and peanut butter. Uhhhhhh, yum!


Armor Sweet Treats Ice Cream Sandwiches / Photo courtesy of Armor Sweet Treats

12. Armor Sweet Treats

4441, 5020 Armor Duells Rd, Orchard Park, NY 14127


Armor Sweet Treats specializes in flavored ice cream for their sandwiches. Keeping the cookie simple, the real flavor lies in the choice of ice cream.


Macaron ice cream sandwich / Photo courtesy of Fig Tree Patisserie

13. Fig Tree Patisserie

3062 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217


Ever had a macaron ice cream sandwich? If not, you’re in luck because Fig Tree Patisserie is making them in multiple flavors.


Red, White, and Blue Sprinkled Ice Cream Sandwiches / Photo courtesy of Frey’s Tasty Treat

14. Frey’s Tasty Treat

6186 S Transit Rd, Lockport, NY 14094


Frey’s Tasty Treat is an ice cream shop located in Lockport with all kinds of ice cream options to choose from. Come by and grab a hold of these ice cream sandwiches and a cute cooling bag to take them home in.


Chocolate/Vanilla Twist Ice Cream Sandwich / Photo courtesy of Adrian’s Custard and Beef

15. Adrian’s Custard and Beef

2352 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, NY 14072


Heading over to Grand Island or live on the island? Stop by Adrian’s Custard and Beef to try out one of their many homemade options – like this one with chocolate / vanilla twist filling on peanut butter cookies. We hear they also have chocolate chip and cookie of the month options.


Anderson’s ice cream sandwich / Photo courtesy of Anderson’s

16. Anderson’s Frozen Custard


With multiple locations around WNY, Anderson’s is a great stop for an ice cream sandwich. They offer the traditional chocolate wafer sandwich with their homemade ice cream and  a variety of candies and sprinkles. A chocolate chip cookie sandwich is offered seasonally.


Creamy Bun / Photo courtesy of Hertel Avenue Poutine & Cream

17. Hertel Avenue Poutine & Cream

1488 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216


Known for their crazy dessert options, Hertel Avenue Poutine & Cream is bringing a whole new level to ice cream sandwiches with their “Creamy Bun” ice cream sandwiches. They partnered with Famous Donuts on Main St. to create these masterpieces which include ice cream and all the toppings you could ever want loaded between a warm glazed donut. What could be better than that?


18. Resurgence Brewing – Chicago St.

55 Chicago St, Buffalo, NY 14204


Resurgence Brewing is providing the classic ice cream sammy. They are keeping it real with vanilla ice cream smushed between two chocolate chip cookies. Sounds good to us!


Nick Charlap's Ice Cream
Chocolate, Vanilla, and Sprinkled Ice cream sandwiches / Photo courtesy of Nick Charlap’s

19. Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream

Multiple locations


Nick Charlap’s has multiple locations serving up some homemade ice cream sandwiches around WNY including Sweets on the Hill in West Seneca. Some of their options include, chocolate, vanilla, sprinkle, and oreo.


100 Acres ice cream sandwiches
100 Acres ice cream sandwich variety pack / Photo courtesy of 100 Acres

20. 100 Acres

444 Forest Ave, Buffalo, NY 14213

Made from homemade cookies and ice cream these summer treats come in a variety pack featuring different flavors.


ice cream sandwich
Photo courtesy of Chrusciki Bakery

21. Chrusciki Bakery

80 W Drullard Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

These ice cream sandwiches or as Chrusciki’s calls them, Cookie Cake Sandwiches, come in flavors or birthday cake, cookies n’ cream, and salted caramel.


Photo courtesy of Hydraulic Hearth

22. Hydraulic Hearth

716 Swan St, Buffalo, NY 14210

Hydraulic Hearth is selling their own homemade chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches out of the “Larkinville Ice House” at the patio bar.


Ice Cream Taco / Photo courtesy of Churn Soft Serve


Why stop at ice cream sandwiches when ice cream tacos exist! Here’s where you can snag an ice cream taco in WNY:

  • Main Street Ice Cream
  • 2 Scoops Ice Cream
  • Churn Soft Serve
  • Hydraulic Hearth
Tags from the story
Ice Cream Seasonal Step Out College
More from Andrea Diedrich

Summer Day Trip: How to Spend a Day in Lockport, New York

Whether you're a local or planning a trip to WNY, here are...
Read More

Leave a Reply