Guide to Brick Oven Pizza in WNY

City Guide, Food & Drink


Written by Kelsie Engert

Published on February 11, 2019
Hearth + Press

Photo courtesy of Hearth + Press

Updated September 2020

If Buffalo takes anything as seriously as it does its wings, it’s pizza. We’ve literally made it into a sixth food group- with more than just your classic pizza shop cheese and pep. Brick ovens are taking pizza to a whole new level – or maybe it’s back to the basics, depending on how you look at it. Either way, we’re not complaining.

Thin, charred crust pie with all the fresh toppings imaginable- it’s fancy af AND delicious. Here are some of our favorite spots to get brick oven pizza around town.

Think we missed one that should be added to this list? Email us at



Elm Street Bakery / Photo x Step Out Buffalo

1. Elm Street Bakery

72 Elm St, East Aurora, NY 14052


Ever since they opened with that big brick oven behind the counter, there’s been pizza at Elm Street. And ever since then, it has truly never disappointed. Get it during lunch or dinner service and expect refined flavor combos that melt in your mouth.


Hearth + Press

Photo courtesy of Hearth + Press

2. Hearth + Press

665 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203


Their 1000 degree stone hearth oven labors Monday through Saturday (and sometimes Sunday) from 10am to 10pm cooking up absolutely GORGEOUS thin-crust pies! Sitting at the bar, you can get a front-row view of the process, but the oven is visible from just about every seat in the house. This place is perfect for just about any occasion- whether it’s a casual lunch break, happy hour, or date night!




Photo courtesy of Woodcock Brothers

3. Woodcock Brothers Brewing Company

638 Lake St, Wilson, NY 14172 + 908 Niagara Falls Blvd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120


Woodcock’s entire menu is crafted from scratch (beer and all) with a special kind of brotherly love. The wood-fired pizza is right on par with the beer- and it is phenomenal. We highly recommend trying out the stuffed pepper or beef on weck pizza -or both. PSA: They are currently working on a second location in the Wurlitzer building in North Tonawanda and we’re pretty freakin’ excited about it!


Brick Oven Bistro Pizza

Brick Oven Bistro / Photo x Step Out Buffalo

4. Brick Oven Bistro

904 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220


This is another spot that takes their pizza toppings just as seriously as the cooking method. Find options like Beef on Weck, “The Brick Mac”, Reuben, and this Stuffed Hot Pepper. BTW gluten free pizzas are available for $2.00 more.



Fried Jerusalem Artichoke, Stewed Onion, Mozz, Fontina, Spice at Hydraulic Hearth / Photo courtesy of Hydraulic Hearth

5. Hydraulic Hearth

716 Swan Street, Buffalo, NY 14210 


This trendy, industrial and rustic brick-walled bar/restaurant focuses primarily on their specialty hearth oven-cooked pizzas. They’ve got 12 to choose from (including a Vegan option and gluten free)- and none of them will disappoint. Aside from the pizza, they’ve got pairable beers brewed in-house by Community Beer Works (okay, so now there’s really no reason for you not to go)! 


Jay's Artisan Pizza

Photo courtesy of Jay’s Artisan Pizza

6. Jay’s Artisan Pizza

2872 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217


If you’ve managed to visit when these guys aren’t sold out for the night, you’ve hit the jackpot for modern neapolitan pizza. The pies here are incredible- especially if you’re a sucker for a solid crust. The pie toppings are so fresh and creatively paired- you’ll want all of the pizzas when you get a look at the menu. Oh, and did we mention they’re also on Skip the Dishes? You can literally order right now, people.


7. 99 Brick Oven Bar & Grill

 99 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086


Located in Lanacaster, 99 Brick Oven Bar & Grill is serving up authentic brick oven pizza. They also just so happen to have a bunch of specials through out the week. Their Tasty Tuesdays feature a keto cheese pizza, Sunday Brunch which features a breakfast pizza, and late night options like their crispy doughy rosettes with dipping sauce.




The Grange Community Kitchen / Photo x Adrianne Salmon

8. The Grange Community Kitchen

22 Main St, Hamburg, NY 14075


That gorgeous white-tiled oven isn’t just for show! It’s cooking up some heavenly pizza pies with all locally-sourced fresh ingredients. Don’t expect to share one either, you’re going to want the entire thing all to yourself. It’s served for both lunch and dinner.


9. Rocco’s Wood-Fired Pizza

5433 Transit Rd, Buffalo, NY 14221


With owners in common with Siena and 800 Maple, you know from the start that Rocco’s Pizza is gonna be good. A wood-fire oven is at the center of their Italian menu, which also features roasted wings, eggplant parmesan, rapini and sausage, meatballs, beans and greens, and more.


pizza amore

Photo courtesy of Pizza Amore

10. Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way”

2024 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, New York
This family business that started in 2011 with a single mobile unit and in 2012 opened a Brick and Mortar on Grand Island. They now we have 4 units and are looking to open another Brick and Mortar. They offer authentic Wood Fire Brick Oven Pizza, Subs, Oven Baked Chicken Wings and Boneless Wings, Fresh Salads, Home Made Pizza Logs, Cannolis and more.


11. Buteras


32 Main St., Hamburg NY 14075

Specializing in the finest craft beers and true brick oven pizzas. Everything on the menu is fresh cuisine with all of their pizzas starting on hand made, hand tossed dough.


pie o mine

Photo courtesy of Pie-O-Mine & Greens

12. Pie-O-Mine


East Amherst, Tonawanda, Orchard Park

Pie-O-Mine offers personalized brick oven pizzas with a variety of specialty options or, guest can create their own. Sizes range anywhere from a slice, to a small pizza, to a large pizza.


13. Belsito


1368 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216

Belsito is known for its traditional Neapolitan style pizzas, made to order & hand stretched. Their menu includes a variety of options as well as the ability to swap out regular crust for a gluten-free cauliflower based crust.


Think we missed one that should be added to this list? Email us at

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Kelsie Engert</a>

Written by Kelsie Engert

Find More ➭ Pizza, Step Out College

Enter your email to get The Insider Hit List - a timely short list of restaurants, things to do and more recommended by the Step Out Buffalo staff.


Forgotten Password?

You must be logged in to use this feature.