13 Spots to Find Buffalo’s Best Polish Food

Polish Platter at Polish Villa / Step Out Buffalo

Updated March 2020

Ah, pierogi. Fortunately for us, Buffalo boasts a plethora of places serving those pillowy pockets of cheesy, potatoey heavenly goodness. We can thank the large number of Polish immigrants for helping establish Buffalo into the pierogi-lovers haven it is today. As time progressed, Polish food evolved, with some eateries now offering pierogi pocketing non-traditional ingredients — pot roast, anyone? — that are fun to explore.


Buffalo also boasts the official “Dyngus Day capital of America” title, meaning we can all share in the fun of Polish traditions. With that in mind, let’s throw off Lenten restrain, ready our pussy willows and celebrate spring with feasts of pierogi, kielbasa and golomki. And let’s not forget the sugary decadence of chrusciki and paczki! This hearty food is for everyone, and, let’s be honest, everyone should be enjoying it not only during springtime but all year round.

Below are some of Western New York’s best spots to find Polish cuisine. We hope you’ll go exploring to find some new favorites but also take time to savor those old standbys that feel like home.

Cieszyc sie! (Polish for, “Enjoy!”)  


The Broadway Market
Photo courtesy of The Broadway Market

1. The Broadway Market

999 Broadway, East Side, 14212 / 716-893-0705


A must-go destination, open year-round, for all the traditional Polish foods from a variety of vendors.


K Sisters
Photo courtesy of K Sisters

2. K Sisters Authentic Pierogi

2116 Clinton St., Cheektowaga, 14206 / 716-827-4077


A pierogi shop – not restaurant – that includes traditional pierogi along with nontraditional varieties, such as fruit, chuck roast and sweet potato.


Rus Pierogi
Ru’s Pierogi / Photo x Step Out Buffalo

3. Ru’s Pierogi

Find in a store near you or follow their food truck.


A twist on traditional Polish cuisine, with many innovative flavors ranging from banana pepper to raspberry tart.


Potts Deli & Grille
Photo courtesy of Potts Deli & Grille

4. Potts Deli & Grille

41 S. Rossler Ave., Cheektowaga / 716-826-6575

Specializing in kielbasa, golomki, breaded pork chops, lazy pierogi and regular pierogi.


5. Polish Nook

2242 Cudaback Ave., Niagara Falls, NY, 14303 / 716-282-6712


Old school bar and restaurant serving traditional Polish favorites.


6. R&L Lounge

23 Mills St., East Side, 14212 / 716-896-5982

A simple comfort food menu in a down-home atmosphere.


7. Gadawski’s Restaurant

1446 Falls St., Niagara Falls, NY 14303 / 716-282-7246


Old school neighborhood bar serving up terrific Polish cuisine.


8. Prosit Restaurant Food Truck

32 North Cayuga Road, Williamsville / 716-239-5742

Serves up Polish food and pastries in a fun, outdoors environment.


9. Gram’s Pierogi House

22 S. Main St., Angola, 14006 / 716-777-3995

Traditional, homemade Polish comfort food.


10. Polish Villa II

1085 Harlem Road, Cheektowaga, 14227 / 716-822-4908


Pierogi, and other Polish classics, in a homey setting.


Polish Villa Reuben / Step Out Buffalo

11. Polish Villa 

2954 Union Rd, Buffalo, NY 14227


The same as Polish Villa II, but not the same. Polish dishes galore.


Mazurek's Bakery
Photo courtesy of Mazurek’s Bakery

12. Mazurek’s Bakery

543 South Park Ave., Buffalo 14204 / 716-853-7833


Bakery with emphasis on Polish favorites, including cheesecake, placzek and poppy seed logs.


Chrusciki Bakery
Photo courtesy of Chrusciki Bakery

13. E.M. Chrusciki Bakery

80 W. Dullard Ave., Lancaster, 14086 / 716-681-9866


Combines old-world gourmet treats, such as chrusciki (obviously!) and paczki, with modern-day fare.

Tags from the story
Seasonal Step Out College
Written By
More from Naomi Sakovics

10 Excellent BBQ Restaurants in WNY

Some of the spots on this list are well known and others...
Read More

Leave a Reply