Nothing says “I love you” like pizza. Sure, there’s champagne, steak dinners, and chocolate-covered strawberries, but this is Buffalo, and we <3 our Za like no one’s business. Fortunately, you can bring that love to an even higher level by ordering that beloved cuisine in the shape of a heart.
Some places will write messages on the box, in toppings – or both. Michael Rizzo, owner of Sports City Pizza Pub, remembers one year using black olives to write “<3 U MarBear” on a pizza. (Awwww!). All are standard pricing, and while most offer the special shape just on Valentine’s Day, some places will offer it year-round. If you want to get a heart-shaped za for yourself and celebrate solo, we support that too, because #selfcare.
In no particular order, here’s where you can get a heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day:
Disclaimer: This is not a complete list and more will be added as they become available.
Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!
ADVERTISEMENT
1. Pizza Plant
- 125 Main St., Buffalo (716) 626-5266
- 7770 Transit Road, Williamsville (716) 632-0800
TO GET THE ZA: Offered February 11-14. Pizza Plant will write messages on top with ricotta cheese. Available in medium size only.
2. Gianni Mazia’s
10325 Main St., Clarence (716) 759-2803
3. Franco’s Pizza
Multiple Locations
TO GET THE ZA: Heart-shaped pizza is available all year (Yes, you heard that right). Available in medium and large sizes.
4. Sports City Pizza Pub
1407 Niagara St., Buffalo (716) 871-8088
TO GET THE ZA: Heart-shaped pizzas will be available February 1-14.
ADVERTISEMENT
5. Just Pizza
Multiple Locations
TO GET THE ZA: For one day only (February 14) Just Pizza will be serving any variety of large size heart shaped pizzas.
6. JJ’s Casa-Di-Pizza
11 E. Mohawk St., Buffalo (716) 883-8200
7. Macy’s Place Pizzeria
3348 Genesee St, Cheektowaga (716) 565-6229
8. Allentown Pizza
94 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo (716) 885-0529
TO GET THE ZA: Get any large pizza in heart shape or any of their large vegan pizzas heart shaped. Offered February 11-15.
ADVERTISEMENT
9. Gino’s Pizza Place
351 Fries Rd, Tonawanda (716) 836-8020
TO GET THE ZA: Heart-shaped pizzas will be offered on February 14, are one-size only, and $20. Pre-orders are welcome.
10. Two Guys Pizza
3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster (716) 896-4897
TO GET THE ZA: Two Guys Pizza will be offering heart-shaped pizzas from February 11-14. They are large size only. Cheese and one topping is $18.99 plus tax and specialty pizzas are $24.99 plus tax.
11. John’s Pizza & Subs
Multiple Locations
TO GET THE ZA: John’s will be offering their large size pizza in a heart shape on both Saturday, February 12, and Monday, February 14.
12. Frankie’s Pizza and Subs
1179 Lincoln Ave, Lockport (716) 434-5114
TO GET THE ZA: Frankie’s Pizza and Subs is offering large heart-shaped pizzas for $17.99 on February 11, 12, and 14. To make it especially unique, they can write a personalized message on the inside of the box.
ADVERTISEMENT
13. Mattina’s Pizzeria
- 6040 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville (716) 626-5550
- 3744 Delaware Ave, Tonawanda (716) 877-5949
TO GET THE ZA: Heart-shaped pizza is offered everyday but pre-orders are recommended for Valentine’s Day.
14. John and Mary’s
40 Buffalo St, Hamburg (716) 648-4750
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-order is recommended
15. Cafora’s Restaurant
2885 Main St, Newfane (716) 778-9069
TO GET THE ZA: Offering a heart-shaped pizza for the last 34 years, Cafora’s will have 16″ pizzas on Friday February 11, Saturday February 12 and Monday February 14.
16. Picasso’s Pizza
Multiple Locations
TO GET THE ZA: Picasso’s is offering “A-pizza-my-heart!” Monday February 14 while supplies lasts.
ADVERTISEMENT
17. Mr. Ventry’s Pizza on the Boulevard
10051 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls (716) 297-1111
18. Nino’s Pizza
- 1737 Orchard Park Rd, West Seneca (716) 674-9066
- 315 Buffalo St, Hamburg (716) 648- 2500
19. Imperial Pizza
1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo (716) 825-3636
20. Sammy’s Pizzeria
1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls (716) 297-8442
TO GET THE ZA: Order over the phone or online. Customers also usually get a pizza cutter with their heart-shaped pizza order.
21. The Now Pizzeria
88 Main St, Hamburg (716) 649-5840
TO GET THE ZA: They will be offering a heart shaped pizza on Valentine’s Day.
Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!
This post was originally published in 2019 and has been updated.
