Originally published February 2019
Nothing says “I love you” like pizza. Sure, there’s champagne, steak dinners, and chocolate-covered strawberries, but this is Buffalo, and we <3 our Za like no one’s business. Fortunately, you can bring that love to an even higher level by ordering that beloved cuisine in the shape of a heart.
Some places will write messages on the box, in toppings – or both. Michael Rizzo, owner of Sports City Pizza Pub, remembers one year using black olives to write “<3 U MarBear” on a pizza. (Awwww!). As if it couldn’t get any better, one place even throws in a box of chocolates. All are standard pricing, and while most offer the special shape just on Valentine’s Day, a couple places will offer it year-round. If you want to get a heart-shaped za for yourself and celebrate solo, we support that too, because #selfcare.
In no particular order, here are the deets on everywhere you can get a heart-shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day:
Did we miss one? Want to add info to your listing? Email us at editorial@stepoutbuffalo.com!
Advertisement
1. Mattina’s Pizzeria (both locations)
6040 Sheridan Drive, Williamsville (626-5550) / 3744 Delaware Ave., Tonawanda (877-5949)
TO GET THE ZA: pre-orders a must. Offered Valentine’s Day only. Available in large size.
2. John and Mary’s (Hamburg location only)
40 Buffalo St., Hamburg (648-4750)
TO GET THE ZA: pre-orders a must. Offered Valentine’s Day only. Available in any size.
3. Pizza Plant (both locations)
125 Main St., Buffalo (626-5266) / 7770 Transit Road, Williamsville (632-0800)
TO GET THE ZA: Offered Feb. 11-17. Will write messages on top with ricotta cheese. Available in medium size.
4. Picasso’s (all locations)
- WILLIAMSVILLE – 6812 Transit Road, Williamsville, NY 14221 / 716.631.0222
- WEST SENECA – 2193 Union Road, West Seneca, NY 14224 / 716.668.1111
- LANCASTER – 5413 Broadway Street, Lancaster, NY 14068 / 716.684.4404
- BLASDELL – 4154 McKinley Parkway #1000, Blasdell, NY 14219 / 716.202.1313
TO GET THE ZA: Call desired location today or order online (week of Valentine’s Day) for pre-orders. Price: $16.25 + tax. Also offering The “JUST FOR 2 HOW CUTE LOVERS COMBO” = heart shaped cheese + 1 topping pizza, 10 wings & breadsticks.
5. Pizza Works
712 Maple Rd, Williamsville, NY / (716)688-5656
TO GET THE ZA: Any Large Pizza can be made into a heart shaped pizza. Call or Order online- request a heart shape when you place your order for a large pizza. Starting at $15.99 (Large Cheese)
6. Gianni Mazia’s
10325 Main St., Clarence (759-2803)
facebook.com/giannimazias10325
TO GET THE ZA: pre-ordesr preferred. Available in size slightly smaller than large. Will write messages on the box.
7. Allentown Pizza
94 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo (885-0529)
facebook.com/Allentownpizza716
TO GET THE ZA: pre-order. Available in large size. Will write messages on box.
Advertisement
8. Franco’s Pizza (all five locations)
1924 Eggert Road, Buffalo (835-7100); 817 Payne Ave., North Tonawanda (692-8181); 1153 Kenmore Ave., Buffalo (877-2720); 2308 Niagara Falls Blvd., Tonawanda (692-3322); 600 Delaware St., Tonawanda (695-3200)
TO GET THE ZA: Heart-shaped pizza available all year (Yes, you heard that right). Available in medium and large sizes.
9. Sports City Pizza Pub
1407 Niagara St., Buffalo (871-8088)
TO GET THE ZA: Available Valentine’s Day, and a few days beforehand. Available in medium and large sizes. Will write messages with toppings.
10. Favorites Pizza & Wings (both locations)
3034 Sweet Home Road, Amherst (564-8880) / 781 Cayuga St., Lewiston (754-8880)
favoritespizza.com/location/lewiston/
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-ordering recommended. Available in a medium size. No messages.
11. Frankie’s Pizza and Subs
1179 Lincoln Ave., Lockport (434-5114)
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-ordering recommended. Available Feb. 14-17. Available in large size. Will write message on box.
12. Just Pizza (Niagara Falls Blvd. location)
2319 Niagara Falls Blvd., Amherst (568-1000)
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-ordering recommended. Available on Valentine’s Day.
13. JJ’s Casa-Di-Pizza
11 E. Mohawk St., Buffalo (883-8200)
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-order. Available in large size. Just on Valentine’s Day. No messages.
Advertisement
14. Nino’s Pizza (both locations)
1737 Orchard Park Road (674-9066) / 315 Buffalo St. (648-2500)
TO GET THE ZA: Available any day of the year. Large size.
15. Cappelli’s Pizzeria
3643 North Buffalo Road, Orchard Park (662-2290)
TO GET THE ZA: Available in large size. Only on Valentine’s Day. No messages.
16. La Nova (both locations)
371 West Ferry St., Buffalo (881-3303) / 5151 Main St., Williamsville (634-5151)
TO GET THE ZA: pre-ordering preferred. Available in large. Will write messages in toppings and box.
17. Bocce Club Pizza (Bailey location only)
4174 North Bailey Avenue Amherst, NY 14226 (716) 833-1344
TO GET THE ZA: Available on Valentine’s Day only. Available in large size. Will write messages in toppings.
Advertisement
18. Mister Pizza
1065 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo (882-6500)
misterpizzaelmwood.com/buffalo-ny-pizzeria.html
TO GET THE ZA: Available in large or medium. Valentine’s Day only. No messages.
19. Bob & John’s La Hacienda (both locations)
1545 Hertel Ave., Buffalo (836-5411) / 2071 Kensington Ave., Amherst (839-5535)
TO GET THE ZA: Available in small and large. Available on Valentine’s Day only. Will write messages on box.
20. Leonardi’s Pizza
614 Grover Cleveland Highway, Amherst (835-8700)
TO GET THE ZA: Available in large size. Valentine’s Day only. Will write messages in toppings or on box.
21. Airport Pizza
3648 Genesee St., Cheektowaga (634-5750)
TO GET THE ZA: Available in small size. Will write messages on box. Available any time of the year.
22. Santora’s Pizza & Catering
2928 Walden Ave., Depew (685-3500)
TO GET THE ZA: Pre-ordering recommended. Available in large size. Will write messages on box.
23. Cafora’s Restaurant
2885 Main Street, Newfane (778-9069)
24. La Hacienda Brighton
900 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda
25. Just Pizza Headquarters
300 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo (883-5650)
Tip: These guys will ship them anywhere nationwide!
26. Gino’s Pizza
351 Fries Road, Tonawanda (836-8020)
27. Two Guys Pizza
3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster ((716) TWO-GUYS)
28. Chick-n-pizza Works
129 Abbot Rd, Buffalo (716-823-1300)
TIP: They also make a shamrock shaped pizza for St Patrick’s Day and a pumpkin shaped Pizza for Halloween!
29. Sammy’s Pizzeria
640 Colvin Blvd, Buffalo 14216 (716-876-0678) and 1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls 14305 (716-297-8442)
TO GET THE ZA: a Large Heart shaped pizza with unlimited toppings is $15.97
30. Mr. Ventry’s Pizza on the Boulevard
10051 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304
31. Wilson’s Pizza Shop
2730 Main Street, Newfane
32. Fatman’s Pizza
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda NY 14150, (716) 693-7477
TO GET THE ZA: Head to Fatman’s where they are offering to write a message on the box for customers. Also, you can purchase a large heart shaped pizza and one item for only $15.99
33. John’s Pizza & Subs
1436 Niagara Falls Blvd., Tonawanda, NY 14150 (716) 832-4343
680 Campbell Blvd., Getzville, NY 14068, (716) 636-8600
2131 Grand Island Blvd., Grand Island, NY 14072, (716) 774-0020
4241 Delaware Ave., Tonawanda, NY 14150, (716) 693-2077
TO GET THE ZA: All locations will serve heart shaped pizzas on 2/14. Call to preorder or order online
34. Avanti Pizza
500 Main St, Medina, (585) 798-1100
310 West Ave, Albion ,(585) 589-8888
35. Tops Markets
All Tops locations except Brattleboro
TO GET THE ZA: They are take and bake, stop by any Tops location and grab cheese, pepperoni, or their famous breakfast pizza. Pizzas are $6-9!
36. Macy’s Place
3348 Genesee St, Cheektowaga, NY 14225, (716) 565-6229
37. DiPaulo’s Pizzeria
571 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda, NY 14150, (716) 835-6161
38. Pizza Amore
2024 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, NY 14072, (716) 775-5975
39. New Ethic Vegan Pizza via Big Mood
Big Mood: 423 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo, NY / 716-768-1878
Heart-shaped pizza from @newethicvegan , double order of wings from @eatbigmood , choice of @drinkolipop or @1911established Rose Cider, and 2 slices of Chocolate Torte from @edencafeandbakeshop . Wow, collab of dreams!
TO GET THE ZA: Orders must be placed by noon on 2/12. Pickup is 2/14 between 4-9PM at Big Mood! Order on our website now, or follow the link in our stories.
Did we miss one? Want to add info to your listing? Email us at editorial@stepoutbuffalo.com!
