Step Out Buffalo's Holiday Gift Guide 2017

City Guide


Written by Claire Johnson

Published on December 6, 2017

Tote Bags from SOB’s new collection at

Finding that perfect gift for all of the different people on your list can be a struggle, we all know this. But checking off that list can actually be a lot of fun if you know where to look. Which is why we scour Western New York shops, websites, and social media to find holiday gift inspo your friends and fam will love. There are so many different shops and artisans in the area, the job gets easier and easier every year, and the options really are endless. Here are just a few of our favorite gift ideas for 2017 from local shops and artisans to get you started.

Featured Shops


No listings were found matching your selection. Something missing? Why not add a listing?.


Buffalo Pallet

❤️ Buffalo Pallet Sign

Perfect for: anyone who loves to show off their love for their city with rustic decor
This rustic sign is made locally in Buffalo, NY, along with a mix of other home decor. Check out this shop for more hand-crafted items, from pallet signs and tea towels to wine glasses and beer coasters.
$15 on CipShopBuffalo’s Etsy Shop online

Buffalo Necklaces

Buffalo Coordinates & Buffalo Native Necklaces

Perfect for: the person who appreciates handmade jewelry
These necklaces are made by local element based jewelry maker Pegs Hardware, sporting the coordinates of our beloved hometown, Buffalo, NY, or simply Buffalo Native. They’re simplistically beautiful and would make a great gift for someone you’ve met in Buffalo or someone that has had to leave the lovely Queen City.
$48.00 at Half and Half Boutique in the Elmwood Village

Take Out Blocks & Recipe Dice

Take Out Blocks & Recipe Dice

Perfect for: your friends who eat out, like, all the time
Either you know someone that needs these, or you are that someone — there’s really no in-between here. We’ve all been there:
“What do you want to eat tonight?” … “Eh, I don’t know, whatever” … “Well, what do you feel like” … “I don’t know, food.”
It’s endless and exhausting, really. These wooden cubes are the end of it. These aren’t just a funny gift, they can save your sanity.
$16.50 from Spoiled Rotten online


Adirondack Nut Butters

Adirondack Nut Butters

Perfect for: that family member who is always eating peanut butter straight from the jar 🙄
We’re obsessed with the idea of giving a collection of these natural nut butters as a super fun, oddball hostess gift. Why? These aren’t your average jar of peanut butter — there’s “Tough Cookie” peanut butter, “Gettin’ Piggy Widdit”, “Honey I Roasted the Peanuts”, “Dashing through the Dough” , “The Dark Side of the Peanut”… must we continue?! Throw a bunch of these together, add in a spoon, and gift it to your peanut butter lovin’ friend. Thank us later.
$7.99+ from Lodgical Homestead Creations

Slipper Socks

Incredibly Soft Slipper Socks

Perfect for: the person who has everything, because you can never have enough comfy socks
Socks are in this year — that sounds weird, but it’s true. Whether they’re covered with hilarious quotes and pictures or made with the softest material you’re foot has ever been graced with, socks are great. Especially if they’re warm, cozy, knitted slipper socks, like these ones at Neo. And they’ve got grips on the bottom so they’re better than any socks or slippers — they’re wonderful.
$25.00 from Neo Gift Studio in the Elmwood Village


Photo from Midgard Winery’s Website

Midgard Honey Wine

Perfect for: wine lovers who are up for trying new things
If you attended the 2017 Buffalo Cocktail Classic or Makers Shakers: Boozy Artisan Market, you know just how great the honey wine from Midgard Winery is. This family owned and operated winery is located in Corfu, NY, where they raise honey bees and create fresh-as-it-gets honey wine. Put together a lovely wine & cheese basket, or pick up a bottle to put with the outdoor wine table above! From the sweet, blueberry wine (made with 100% NYS blueberries), to a sweet wine with a kick (the Nordic Fire), whoever you’re gifting this to is in for a treat.
$15-$24 at these locations across WNY

Travel Kit

Traveller’s Dream Kit

Perfect for: the traveler
This one takes some work, but we did the hard part for you. You can pick and choose or make one grand basket, combining a leather passport wallet with the Citizens of the World Sketchbook, and a cocktail kit (or three) and you’ve got a brilliant gift for the person on your list whose constantly traveling. The passport wallet is logical, the Citizens of the World is thought-provoking, and the cocktails just make any flight 500x better. Bonus: you can get all of these with one stop to Fern + Arrow.
Passport Wallet: $26.00, Citizens of the World Sketch Book: $12.00, Cocktail Kit: $24.00 at Fern + Arrow

2 in 1: Comb & Bottle Opener

Perfect for:
We had a hard time picking just one thing on our trip to Fern + Arrow, so we didn’t. For the guy on your list, we’d combine this oddly useful, stainless steal Beard & Mustache Comb Bottle Opener with a Whiskey & How to Enjoy it Giftset (complete with two hefty 8oz whiskey tumblers, two leather coasters, and a whiskey guidebook), and maybe throw in some whiskey stones for good measure. All of which you can get at Fern + Arrow in the Elmwood Village. Stop by Tommyrotter Distillery to grab a bottle of their locally made American Whiskey to really send this gift set over the top.
[Beard & Mustache Comb Bottle Opener: $22, Whiskey & How to Enjoy it Giftset: $35, Whiskey Stones: $22 at Fern + Arrow] and [ Bottle of Tommyrotter American Whiskey can be found at these locations]

Featured Shops


No listings were found matching your selection. Something missing? Why not add a listing?.


Custom Couple Portrait // Photo from Etsy

Custom Portraits

Perfect for: newlyweds/new parents/new pet parents/housewarming gift
These are absolutely adorable and we’re seriously buying one for every cute couple, family, and dog we know. The shop is called “Tiny Buffalo Designs” and everything is custom created, from cards to portraits and ornaments. The artist, Lauren, is incredibly detailed, down to getting the tattoos on someone’s arm perfect. This is a great gift for any recently married couples, a family that has just moved into a new home, or really any cute duo you know, like you and your dog… not that I’m doing that.
$50-$90 from TinyBuffaloDesignsCo Etsy shop (depending on size & number of figures)

Available on for $15

Life is Better in Buffalo Tote

Perfect for: Your friend to goes to the market more than anyone you know
Everyone knows that life is better in Buffalo, so here’s a little extra reminder. These totes, designed by yours truly (Step Out Buffalo), are perfect for the loud and proud Buffalonians, the eco-friendly shoppers, and really anyone out there that uses a bag ever (i.e., everyone and anyone). Head to our brand new online shop to see our full line of tote bags along with T-shirts and long sleeves.
$15 from Step Out Buffalo Shop online

Buffalo Shadow Box

Buffalo Shadow Box

Perfect for: The thoughtful friend you know will appreciate it
If you have any family or close friends that have left Buffalo, this may be the perfect gift — especially if you’re a bit creative. Toss in some tickets from a show you attended, little pebbles from your favorite park, or other little keepsakes that’ll bring back sweet mems. This could be the most heartfelt gift of the season.
$42 from Buffalo Adore in Downtown Buffalo or online

You Gotta Know Buffalo Game

You Gotta Know Buffalo — My Hometown Edition

Perfect for: The friends who loves to stay in & chill
This trivia game covers everything Buffalo, testing even the truest Buffalonians at heart. Apparently its Buffalo’s “Gift of the Year.”
$20 from Store716 online

Rusterior’s Plaid Buffalo Bison Baseball Tee

Screen Printed Plaid Buffalo Bison Baseball Tee

Perfect for: The plaid-lover in your life – help ’em mix it up
This tee was the star of the show at Step Out’s recent Makers + Shakers: Boozy Artisan Market on Small Business Saturday, so we knew it had to make the list. Check out the rest of Rusterior’s Buffalo-themed gear while you’re at it, from baseball caps to cozy sweatshirts.
$32 from Rusterior online

Buffalo Spirit Jerseys

Buffalo Spirit Jerseys

Perfect for: The Buffalo fan-girl in your life
Everyone loves spirit jerseys — they’re comfy, sporty, and trendy all at the same time. What more could you ask for from a shirt? Any Western New Yorker or Buffalo fan is sure to love this gift.
$49 from Sunshine & Bluebirds in Elmwood Village, Orchard Park, or the Galleria Mall

Photo from Buffalo Bloody Mary Fest 2017

Tickets to the Buffalo Bloody Mary Fest

Perfect for: Your friends/fam who are all about Instagramming epic experiences  (pro tip: make sure they love Bloody Marys first!)
Trust us, giving the gift of a Sunday Funday is always a good idea. This is all anyone on your list who is 21+ and loves Bloody Marys needs to get them through the Buffalo winter that’s about to hit us. If you want to be a bit crafty with the gift, print out the tickets, roll them up in a fun glass with bloody mary mix and a brunch-themed t-shirt and throw it in a Sunday Funday tote bag. They’ll be spending they’re day tasting and judging the most deliciously concocted Bloodys in Western New York. Plus you can’t buy this gift without buying one for yourself, right? RIGHT.
$35 – $60, tickets go on sale on Wednesday, Dec. 6 online at

We launched a new look!

Our new design features a better browsing experience, modern mobile navigation, more visual displays of key info, better filtering options on the search page, and much more.

We hope you love our new look! That said, we’re #ForeverTweaking and would greatly appreciate your feedback so we can make *all* you want and need as your go-to resource for the best of Western New York!

Send feedback >

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Claire Johnson</a>

Written by Claire Johnson

Find More ➭ Step Out College


Forgotten Password?

You must be logged in to use this feature.