Can’t Top the Tapas at Elm Street Bakery

Food & Drink, Food & Drink News


Written by Homer Enthusiast

Published on April 23, 2015

Photography by Machelle Pohlman

Perfection? Seems so technical. Brilliant? Sure it applies but somehow misses the point. Magnificent? As in impressively beautiful, elaborate, or extravagant; striking? Yes, magnificent.

Chef Brad Rowell and the crew at Elm Street Bakery hit it out of the ball park at the inaugural Step Out Buffalo “Adventures in Food” event April 21st. We’re talking a Reggie Jackson, three home runs in the World Series type night. It’s hard to put into words how good the food was so we’ll just tease you with a list and some photos (by Machelle Pohlman). Feel free to drool. As good as they sound/look – double it. The eighteen different “Spanish” tapas with an Elm Street touch were quite simply magnificent.

In the interest of full disclosure this was a Step Out Buffalo sponsored event. Yes, we do have a horse in the race, but believe me when I tell you I could not possibly over state the magnificence of the taste, presentation and the entire evening.


RELATED: Elm Street Bakery Kills Secret Brunch


The Night

This was the first in what we hope to be many Adventures in Food with Step Out Buffalo. Adventure #1: The restaurant was closed to the public. Advanced ticket purchase required, limited to 70 people. Half a dozen stations were set up around the restaurant where people helped themselves to tapas. There were two drink areas set up serving Spanish wines, cava, and house made sangria. Spanish music played from the balcony by The Troubadours. People sat, stood, walked, mingled, and chatted with staff about their amazing creations. It was hard to tell who was more excited, creator or patron.

Thanks to the entire Elm Street team for making adventure #1 a smashing success:  (Servers) Rachel Cappola, Joanna Cappola, Mary Bennett, Katy Abrams; (Cooks) Head Chef Brad Rowell, Chad Robasse, Anthony Petrilli, RJ Marvin, Mike Thurkins; (Pastry) Emily Savage ;Caryn Rowell (General Manager), Kim DePerno (Owner), and Sandy Stimers from Wildman.


Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, White Anchovies with piperade on toast

White Anchovies with piperade on toast / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

The Tapas Menu

Tortilla Espanola with romesco and aioli

Tortilla Espanola is popular throughout Spain. It’s essentially a frittata made with onions and potatoes. Romesco is a traditional Spanish sauce made with bread, almonds, garlic, tomatoes, peppers, and olive oil.

Mussels en escabeche, pimenton, toast

The mussels are steamed and removed from the shell. They are then marinated with sherry vinegar, olive oil, celery, red onion, and garlic. The crostini is spread with a pimento aioli.

White Anchovies with piperade on toast

Piperade is a mix of roasted peppers, onions, garlic, and tomatoes stewed together. The finished product is slightly sweet and smoky. The piperade will be placed on toasted baguette and topped with a white anchovy.

Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, Eggs with sea urchin on baguette

Eggs with sea urchin on baguette / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

Eggs with sea urchin on baguette

The eggs are soft scrambled with crème fraiche. We will place the eggs on top of toasted baguette and garnish with a piece of sea urchin, a splash of sherry vinegar and minced chives.

Sauteed Chickpeas with pea shoots, pimenton, olive oil

The chickpeas are cooked in salted water with dried chilis and garlic. We then sauté them with garlic, olive oil, pimenton and toss in the fresh pea shoots at the end. (Pimenton is smoked, hot Spanish paprika).

Chicken liver mousse stuffed dates with marcona almond, and sherry vinegar

The chicken liver mousse is stuffed inside of dates and and the end is filled with a marcona almond. We will drizzle these with a sherry vinegar gastrique.

Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, Soft boiled egg with confit garlic and mojama

Soft boiled egg with confit garlic and mojama / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

Ajo Blanco with grapes and marcona almonds

Ajo blanco is a chilled soup made with bread, almonds, fennel, garlic, olive oil, sherry vinegar, salt and pepper. It will be topped with marcona almonds and sliced grapes.

Idiazabal with membrillo

Spanish D.O. (Denominacion de Origen) standards rule that this Basque country favorite must be made with the raw milk of Laxta and Carranza sheep, lightly pressed and aged for 2-10 months. Smoking is an optional touch, reflecting a history of hanging wheels near a fireplace to dry. Ours is lightly smoked, and aged only 2-3 months. We like the supple, toothsome texture at this point and the subtle sharpness before it becomes hot with more age. The special sheep give exceptionally rich, fatty milk, resulting in a buttery mouth-feel and an intriguing gamy character. Best enjoyed hearthside with a mug of hard cider or a fruity Spanish red. House made membrillo (aka quince paste) is spread on crostini and topped with a small wedge of idiazabal.

Soft boiled egg with confit garlic and mojama

Eggs are soft boiled and sliced in half. The garlic confit is pureed until smooth and will be dolloped on top of the egg. The egg is then topped with grated mojama (Cured Spanish tuna loin).


Made using the loins of the tuna by curing them in salt for two days. The salt is then removed, the loins are washed and then laid out to dry in the sun and the breeze (according to the traditional method) for fifteen to twenty days.

It is usually served in extremely thin slices with olive oil and chopped tomatoes or almonds. In Madrid mojama is very popular mid afternoon tapa and is served with a short beer and olives.


Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, Pig head fritter with piquillo pepper puree and quail eggs

Pig head fritter with piquillo pepper puree and quail eggs / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

Salt Cod Croquette, Oyster aioli, pimento

House made salt cod is cooked with milk, shallots, garlic, olive oil, and potatoes and parsley. This is roughly pureed together and then breaded with bread crumbs that have been mixed with vegetable ash. The croquette is then fried until crispy. We will dollop with an aioli made with roasted oysters and sprinkle with pimenton.

Pig head fritter with piquillo pepper puree and quail eggs

Pig heads are cooked with mirepoix, and white wine until tender. We then pull the meat and toss with roasted shallots, roasted garlic, thyme, and Dijon mustard. The meat is cooled and then cut into small squares. We then bread and fry them until crispy. We top them with a puree piquillo peppers ( a traditional Spanish pepper) and then a fried quail egg.

RJ’s Pickle Platter

Various pickled items including chorizo, eggplant, garlic, basque peppers

Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, Fideo with clams and chicken, saffron aioli

Fideo with clams and chicken, saffron aioli / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

Fideo with clams and chicken, saffron aioli

This fideo is prepared with a tomato broth, toasted pasta, chicken and clams. This is all roasted in the wood oven and dolloped with saffron aioli.

Gambas Al Ajillo

Head on tiger shrimp are roasted in the wood oven with garlic, pimento, sherry vinegar, and parsley.

Padron peppers with salbitxada

Peppers are roasted with olive oil and salt. They will be served with salbitxada (sal-bit-chada), a Spanish sauce made with chilis, almonds, tomato, garlic, egg yolk, and canola oil.

Tapas Night at Elm Street Bakery - Step Out Buffalo, Creme Caramel

Creme Caramel / Photo by Machelle Pohlman

Creme Caramel

Coconut shortbread

Torrone dipped in Chocolate

Spanish style nougat with marcona almonds


Sweet potato, honey, and almond cookie from Catalonia


Saffron and sea salt


Sign up to be notified by email about our next “Adventure in Food” below and follow 5 Plates on Facebook…

[mc4wp_form id=”72954″]


You might also find interesting…

[justified_image_grid preset=4 row_height=155 height_deviation=1 prettyphoto_social=yes prettyphoto_analytics=yes caption=fixed mobile_caption=same timthumb_crop_zone=t limit=3 hidden_limit=6 max_rows=1 aspect_ratio=16:9 disable_cropping=no recent_posts=yes recents_description=nicetime recents_include=food-drink post_ids_exclude=current]



We launched a new look!

Our new design features a better browsing experience, modern mobile navigation, more visual displays of key info, better filtering options on the search page, and much more.

We hope you love our new look! That said, we’re #ForeverTweaking and would greatly appreciate your feedback so we can make *all* you want and need as your go-to resource for the best of Western New York!

Send feedback >

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Homer Enthusiast</a>

Written by Homer Enthusiast

A born and bred Buffalover.
Find More ➭


Forgotten Password?

To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
You must be logged in to use this feature.