5 of The Craziest Bloody Marys You’ll Find in WNY

Brunch, City Guide, Food & Drink, Food & Drink Guides


Written by Kelsie Engert

Published on October 24, 2019

Due to COVID-19 some availability in this article may have changed since publishing. Check with establishments directly before visitng.

Photo courtesy of Cask & Cow

When in Buffalo, sometimes you just want to eat large (amirite?). Luckily, we certainly don’t fall short when it comes to our fave brunch drink. There are some wildly outrageous bloodies that live right here in the Queen City- and we’re about to uncover them, so pull up a chair (seriously, these things are a meal and a half). TBH if you’re not doing a bloody mary like these places, you’re doing it all wrong.

Here are some of the craziest Bloody Mary’s in WNY: 

1. Cask + Cow

840 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092 / WEBSITE

This hip Lewiston restobar specializes in juicy gourmet burgers, so why not throw it on the most iconic cocktail of all time? Cask + Cow’s bloody is decked out to the max with a cheeseburger slider, bacon, lemon and lime slices, and green olives.


2. Cole’s

1104 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, New York 14222 / WEBSITE

On their Sunday Brunch menu, you’ll find a section titled “Bloody Pints”- that’s right, 16 oz. of pure bloody goodness. They’ve got 12 (!!) different bloody flavors, including a Buffalo bloody with Frank’s and bleu cheese and a chipotle bacon bloody with a spicy kick.

3. JJ’s Casa di Pizza

11 E Mohawk St, Buffalo, NY 14203 / WEBSITE

Don’t expect a celery stick on your bloody mary this time but instead, a greasy slice of pizza (*with the only kind of pepperoni we know- cup and char) drooping over the edges of your glass. It’s available daily with the pizza slice, but on Sundays from noon until the bar dies down, they’re only $5! We repeat: $5. For an entire meal.


Photo courtesy of Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.

4. Rusty Nickel Brewing Company

4350 Seneca St., West Seneca, NY 14224 / WEBSITE

Whether you try their original bloody mary, Let’s Taco Bout Mary or Mary Mango Hoptrot, you’re guaranteed a pile of crazy good garnishes- possibly a Ru’s pierogi or a mango chunk. And to top it off, they’ll toss on a GetLinked smoked sausage that pairs perfectly with a bloody. And yes, they’ve been known to kill it at the Buffalo Bloody Mary Fest.

Photo courtesy of Sidelines

5. Sidelines

189 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14202 / WEBSITE

With a make-your-own bloody mary bar like Sidelines, there are literally no boundaries. You might just end up with a pierogi or a whole chicken finger on your bloody. We’re not complaining either way.

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Kelsie Engert</a>

Written by Kelsie Engert

Find More ➭ Craziest Guides

Similar Articles You'll Love...

Haunted & Halloween Guides


Forgotten Password?