The Ultimate Buffalo Fall Bucket List

City Guide, Things to Do


Written by Morgan Culhane

Published on September 15, 2022
Holiday Valley in Ellicottville / Photo courtesy of Holiday Valley

Temperature drops and Bills Mafia madness aren’t the only changes fall brings. With autumn comes a whole new list of fun things to do around Buffalo and Western New York. From leaf peeping, pumpkin patching, and apple picking to frights, pumpkin spice and fall bites, there’s so much to do before the snow flies! Here are some must do activities to add to your Buffalo bucket list this fall:

Ultimate Buffalo Fall Bucket List

1. Go Apple Picking- Pick your own apples at a local apple orchard, such as Becker Farms in Gasport or Smith’s Orchard Cider Mill in Lockport. Check out our full guide to apple orchards here!

2. Go Pumpkin Picking- Visit a pumpkin farm to find your canvas to carve the perfect jack-o’lantern. Explore favorites like The Great Pumpkin Farm in Clarence, Wheatfield Pumpkin Farm in North Tonawanda, or Pumpkinville in Great Valley – they always have other fun stuff for the kids to do on top of harvesting your pick of pumpkins. You can check out our pumpkin patch guide here!

3. Restock Your Fall Wardrobe- Scarves, sweaters, boots, oh my! There are so many great spots to shop local – check out our Shopping Guides by Neighborhood for inspo.


4. Tailgate at a Bills Game- Get your Bills gear, booze, and snacks to catch a home game at Highmark Stadium. Find the best bars to hit pre and post Bills game here.

5. Find Your Fall Signature Drink- It’s no secret that fall brings the best bevys – both alcoholic and non. Whether you need your pumpkin spice latte fix every morning via a fancy caffeinated beverage, you can’t get enough pumpkin beer, or craft cocktails are your jam, there are so many great spots to drink local while you feed your inner *basic*.

6. Make a trip to Ellicottville- Fall is the best time of year for an Ellicottville adventure filled with beautiful foliage. Ride the chairlift to the top of the hill at Holiday Valley to catch the best view of the changing leaves or try out Holiday Valley’s Adventure Park. Need an itinerary? Check out our guide to Ellicottville here.

7. Attend a Fall Fest- Get the whole family together to enjoy a day of fall-themed fun. There’s tons of festivals happening this season, find a list of them happening this weekend and beyond here!

8. See a Rocky Horror Movie- If you’ve never been to a Rocky Horror Show, nows the time to check it out! A few local theaters around town host screening sessions of this classic film during the Halloween festivities. Check out our guide here.


9. Get Spooked at a Haunted House- A good scare is a fall-must, try not to chicken out when you visit Frightworld on Hertel or Fright Fest at Darien Lake. Check out all the haunted house attractions in WNY here!

10. Visit a *Real* Haunted Place – Want something a bit more authentically haunted? Check out our Guide to the Most Haunted Places in WNY and visit if you dare…

11. Celebrate Oktoberfest– Hit up one of Buffalo’s breweries to try seasonal Oktoberfest beers or make the venture to one of many events happening in WNY!

12. Hunt Down the Best Homemade Apple Cider Donuts in Town When fall comes around, if you’re not looking for every chance to get your hands on one of these sugary creations, then you are doing fall all wrong. We’ve got your back with our handy guide to apple cider donuts here.

13. Go on a Guided Haunted Walk/Tour/Pub Crawl- Book a tour to experience some haunting stories and possibly some paranormal activity. Get spooked on one of these Haunted Tours & Walks in WNY.

14. Go on a Fall-themed or Haunted Hayride – Something about tractors and creepy dirt paths make haunted hayrides extra frightening. There are plenty of options to choose from including Becker Farms and newcomer to Niagara County, The Haunted Forest. Check out our Complete Guide to Fall and Haunted Hayrides Happening All Over WNY.

15. Take a Foliage Filled Hike- Seeing the leaves change colors makes for a picture-perfect backdrop while hiking. We’ve got some popular fall hiking spots worth checking out here. Plus check out these guides:2 Extraordinary Fall Hikes Worth the Drive from Buffalo and 9 Places to See Fall Leaves in WNY.

16. Attend a Theater Show – Theater is back in Buffalo, baby! Don’t let this theater season go by without attending a show at one of the many local performance theaters across WNY.

17. Have a Last Chance Bonfire- Tell scary stories and roast s’mores around the campfire before the entire city is covered in feet of snow for months.

18. Visit a Cider Mill- Nothing’s quite as crisp as fresh-pressed cider in autumn. Get your fill at Smith’s Orchard Cider Mill in Lockport or Mayer Brothers in West Seneca.


19. Have a Magical Movie Marathon- If you don’t already own them, you can rent, stream, or tune in to a TV special to watch Hocus Pocus, Friday the 13th, Halloweentown, Casper, It’s The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown, The Addams Family, Jeepers Creepers, and all the other classics.  And if you want to leave your house, check out our guide to locally owned movie theaters.

20. Get Lost in a Corn Maze- Navigate your way through the twists and turns with your kids and family friends at The Great Pumpkin Farm in Clarence (which also has an entire Halloween-themed bar and you should 10/10 go visit it). Plus check out our Guide to Places to Get Lost in a Corn Maze This fall in WNY.

21. Host a Friendsgiving- Invite all your chosen family over, prepare all your favorite dishes, and restock your liquor cabinet to enjoy an evening of friendship and gratitude.

22. Take a Fall Drive – WNY is consistently rated one of the best places in the United States to view the changing autumn leaves, so why not take advantage of the fact that you live here and go see ‘em? Here are 6 Beautiful Fall Drives that will make you fall in love with fall more than you can imagine.

23. Hop On a Fall Foliage Train Ride – If you want to cherish peak autumn with an unmatched experience – there’s truly no better way to soak in the sights than a fall foliage train ride. Check out our Guide to Fall Foliage Train Rides to Take in WNY.

24. Taste Test Buffalo Bills-Themed Beers by Local Breweries – Can’t think of a better way to show your hometown spirit than tracking down these Buffalo Football themed beers brewed right here in Bills Country. Can you? Here’s a guide to the Bills-Themed Beers you need in your life.

25. Enjoy a Murder Mystery Experience – From dinner parties to bus tours, there are multiple exciting (and legal) ways to find yourself in the middle of a murder mystery this season.

Did one of these places close? Send us a note!

This post was originally published in 2017 and has been updated.

Fall Guides

We launched a new look!

Our new design features a better browsing experience, modern mobile navigation, more visual displays of key info, better filtering options on the search page, and much more.

We hope you love our new look! That said, we’re #ForeverTweaking and would greatly appreciate your feedback so we can make *all* you want and need as your go-to resource for the best of Western New York!

Send feedback >

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Morgan Culhane</a>

Written by Morgan Culhane

Morgan is a storyteller with a passion for exploring Buffalo's food and beverage scene. She enjoys drinking craft beer so much that she started a business dedicated to promoting this industry. As the co-founder of Content on Draft, she develops social media marketing strategies for craft beverage companies in Buffalo and beyond… and she loves it!


Forgotten Password?

To save to your favorites you must login first.
Login Here
You must be logged in to use this feature.