Your Ultimate Guide to the Biggest Burritos in WNY

Written by SOB Creative
Published on July 2, 2019

Bacon Cheeseburger Burrito / Photo x Cantina 62

Updated October 2020

In Buffalo, bigger is always better. Citizens of the 716 go big or go home when it comes to pretty much everything you can think of, including burritos. Buffalo is home to MANY local Mexican taquerias and restaurants that are serving up this fan favorite dish, but which ones are thinking bigger when it comes to giving the people what they want? Let’s taco bout’ it!

Here’s our official guide to the restaurants serving up the biggest burritos in WNY. And if you can’t finish one of these mega-burritos, challenge accepted, then share with a friend or take it to go. We highly recommend pairing a margarita with any burrito ordered.

Know of any other places in the 716 serving up larger than life burritos? Tell us about it at!


Burrito Bay

Photo courtesy of Burrito Bay

1. Burrito Bay

2341 Millersport Highway, Amherst / 716-688-6070 

Home of the Glutton Burrito, Barito Bay is dishing out this mammoth of a burrito which can be ordered with chicken, beef, pork, buffalo chicken, steak or beans. So big you’ll have to eat it with two hands.


2. Arriba Tortilla

40 Riley St., East Aurora / 716-714-9176

From monster sized enchiladas, to larger than life burritos and chimichangas, this place has you covered. You can even turn any burrito into a “Bacon Bandit” by adding, you guessed it!, bacon!


Photo x Deep South Taco


3. Deep South Taco

291 Ellicott Street, Buffalo  / 6727 Transit Road, Lancaster / 1707 Hertel Ave, Buffalo

All of DST’s burritos are weighing in at a whopping 1lb or 3lb. Your choice! But wait, there’s more! If you and a friend are craving the same thing, you are more than welcome to order the full-sized 7lb Lucha-rito. Pick a protein and this burrito will come with cilantro rice, charro beans, ghost pepper cheese, chihuahua cheese, 3 cheese tequila queso, salsa fresca, cabbage, jalapeño, green onion and cilantro, smothered in red chili mole sauce and cotija cheese. Did someone say cheese?



Cantina 62’s Nachorrito / Step Out Buffalo

4. Cantina 62

2178 Seneca Street, Buffalo /  716-333-8226

Not only are there traditional tacos and burritos on the menu, Cantina 62 has thought outside the box to bring Buffalonians unique Mexican-American cuisine too. You can turn any taco into a burrito or order Cantina’s specialty bacon cheeseburger, bbq pork quesarrito, nachorrito or tropical fish burritos! Want to use a knife and fork? Order a fried burrito bowl! Pro tip: the Nachorrito is especially large.

Photo courtesy of El Cubilete

5. El Cubilete Best Mexican Cuisine

2050 Cayuga Drive Extension, Niagara Falls, NY 14304 / 716-297-4500

Craving a very large burrito? Of course you are, you’re on this post. Anyways, look no further – you can literally order just that at El Cubilete. The “Mucho Grande Burrito” can be made with chicken or steak cooked with onions, and filled with tomatoes, bell peppers, rice, beans, sour cream, lettuce, cheese dip and burrito sauce.


6. La Galera Mexican Restaurant

8215 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls / 716-283-0005

What’s better than one big burrito? FOUR big burritos! You can order the Burrito Mojado, Burrito Cancun, Burrito California or the Burrito Ranchero here! If that’s not enough, then the Burrito Supremo, filled with steak and chicken, is for you!



7. Don Tequila Mexican Bar & Restaurant

73 Allen Street, Buffalo / 716-939-2552

Don’s Tequila’s Burrito Grande puts the “b” in big! This burrito is stuffed with pork chunks and beans and served with rice, salad and ranchero sauce. Or, check out the California Burrito, filled with steak or chicken, rice and beans, and topped with nacho cheese, green sauce and cream salad. Mmmm


8. Auguacates Mexican Bar & Grill

5674 S Transit Road, Lockport / 716-280-3785

Jumbo Burritos filled with ground beef and topped with lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes! Need we say more? Need a little more kick? Order the spicy Big Aguacate Burrito that is covered in hot guacamole! You may or may not need a glass of milk afterwards.


9. Los Compadres Mexican Taqueria

40 Oak Street, Batavia / 585-250-4067

Not only does this taqueria serve breakfast, it offers a jumbo California burrito that can be paired with some cheap drinks! This flour tortilla is filled with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, sour cream and your choice of meat. But that’s not all! It’s then covered with cheese and green sauce!



10. Steveo’s Tacos & Subs

 6811 Erie Rd, Derby, NY 14047 / 716-947-9146

You know Steveo’s makes this list when its burrito sizes range from jumbo to triple jumbo. As for building your burrito, the offer beef, bbq chicken, tuna, chicken finger, steak, crab, and more!


11. Andale Mexican Restaurant

9416 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051 / 716-428-3068

From the look of it, Andale Mexican Restaurant is serving up a bunch of huge burrito platters like their Santa Fe Burrito and the Burrito Villa. But as the name entails, the Mucho Grande Burrito is fit for this list. What’s in this creation? One big burrito filled with your choice of grilled chicken or steak cooked with onions and bell peppers, rice, beans, sour cream and lettuce with cheese dip and burrito sauce.


12. Maizal Mexican Kitchen and Mezcaleria

4754 N French Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051 / 716-428-5683

The burrito that Maizal has to offer is simply put, the Ultimate Burrito, or as they describe it, “the last burrito you’ll ever need.” Using two tortilla shells, this burrito is 16 inches in size and is filled with your choice of protein, rice, beans, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onions, jalapenos, sour cream, and guacamole.


Know of any other places in the 716 serving up larger than life burritos? Tell us about it at!


SOB Creative







Forgotten Password?