19 Places to Get Valentine's Day Sweets

Food & Drink


Written by Jessica Kelly

Published on February 11, 2016

Blue Table Chocolates

Photo from Blue Table Chocolates

Hey all you procrastinators, still haven’t bought chocolates or something sweet for your sweetie for the big day? Maybe you listened to her when she said she doesn’t want anything for Valentine’s Day? Here’s a little hint for you, if she says she doesn’t want anything; she’s lying!  We’ve created the sweetest list around town packed full of sugary gifts to shower your loved one with. Cupcakes?  No problem! The best sponge candy and salted caramels? We’ve got you covered!
Blue Table Chocolates

Blue Table Chocolates / Photo from Blue Table Chocolates

Blue Table Chocolates

345 West Ferry in Buffalo / (716) 866-3725
Blue Table Chocolates will have their usual 12 flavors available which include some unique finds like sesame crunch and coconut passion fruit along with two flavors of the month; vanilla hibiscus and passion fruit.  And just in time for V-day they launched a series of luxury candy bars that look just as beautiful as their chocolates!  Check out their Facebook and for new flavors and pop up shop locations.  These shimmery chocolate truffles and candy bars are sure to impress inside and out.  Also available at the Horsefeathers Winter Market on Saturdays.
More Info

Alethea’s Chocolates

8301 Main St. in Buffalo / (716) 633-8620

For Valentines Day Alethea’s is offering a special Tuxedo for Two Box (or one…let’s be honest, who wants to share), chocolate filled Valentines, solid chocolate hearts, sponge candy hearts, and more. Pro tip: their cherry cordials are to die for!
More Info

Antoinette Sweets

5981 Transit Rd. in Depew / (716) 684-2376
When you go to Antoinette’s to pick up some of their famous sponge candy, enjoy a decadent hot fudge sundae and make yourself at home. For Valentine’s Day (this Friday-Sunday) they are offering chocolate covered strawberries that look phenomenal!
More Info


Anatomical Hearts from Sweet Jenny’s / Photo via Sweet Jenny’s

Sweet Jenny’s Ice Cream

5732 Main St. in Williamsville / (716) 631-2424

With sweets set up at this location and at the Old Red Mill off of Main Street near Glen Park, Sweet Jenny’s is the talk of Main Street. I highly recommend their French silk chocolates, they just melt in your mouth. Also, they have Anatomical Hearts! Come on!
More Info

Oh Pour L’amour Du Chocolat 

4476 Main St. in Buffalo / (716) 240-9815

If your valentine loves Paris and dessert, this is the shop for you!  With everything from ice cream, dragées, and candies to French macarons and chocolate covered strawberries, you’ll probably end up leaving with an arm full of goodies for your date.
More Info

Parkside Candy

3208 Main St. in Buffalo / (716) 833-7540
Parkside Candy will not only reel you in with their sweet treats, but salty, as well!  Head to Parkside Candy for their chocolate covered pretzels or popcorn for the salty sweet lovers in your life. For a complete list of locations, click here.
More Info


738 Elmwood Ave. in Buffalo / (716) 884-3216
Hands down, without a doubt, the BEST salted caramel chocolates around. The flavors are out of this world and I love the large pieces of coarse salt stuck to the top of each chocolate.  I think it’s clear what my favorite Watson’s item is, but they’re also well known for having the best butter crunch chocolates and great assortments. For a complete list of locations, click here.
More Info

Fowler’s in the Buffalo Harbor Center

75 Main St. in Buffalo / (716) 424-1180
Looking for a unique way to keep the chocolates coming?  In addition to assorted chocolates, these guys offer a membership for Fowler’s Chocolate of the Month Club (3 month, 6 month, and 9 month options)!  For a complete list of locations, click the link.
More Info


Photo from Baked Cupcakery

Baked Cupcakery

1879 Whitehaven Rd. in Grand Island / (716) 773-2050
5428 Main St. in Williamsville / (716) 276-8977
While Baked Cupcakery’s cupcake flavors change regularly, you can count on seeing Chocolate Covered Strawberry, Strawberries and Champagne, Red Velvet, White Wedding, Chocolate and Red Wine, Death by Box of Chocolates, Cherry Amaretto, and Breakfast in Bed for Valentine’s Day! They’ll also add personalized messages if you want. #willyoumarryme
More Info

DiCamillo Bakery

5329 Main St. in Williamsville / (716) 635-6504
DiCamillo’s cookies and baked goods are a delicious treat for your valentine. Pick up a box of cookie mosaic, biscotti clusters, and Linzer Heart Tins for Valentine’s Day! For a complete list of locations, click the link.
More Info

Heart Shaped Oreos by @butterblockbuffalo

Heart Shaped Oreos by @butterblockbuffalo

Butter Block Pop Up Shop

Various Locations – Find out where they’ll be next!
Planning a Sunday brunch for your babe? We’ve raved about their PopTarts their Oreos, but their buttery croissants and pain au chocolate are amazing as well. Plus, they’re teaming up with Fern Croft and Peg’s Hardware this year for a flower / jewelry / chocolates package for your sweetie. Call/Email to place your order, or stop in this week to Fern Croft @ 291 Bryant Street!
More Info

Wolter’s Bakery

5225 Sheridan Dr. in Buffalo / (716) 632-3212

Their display is packed with sugar cookies and sweet treats to choose from, but my favorite has to be the almond ring. A large ring would make a great dessert after your Valentine’s Day dinner.

Firefly Cupcakes

700 Main St. in East Aurora / (716) 655-4949
If you’re more into cakes than candy, Firefly has delicious cupcake flavors like chocolate Explosion (dark chocolate cake with chocolate silk laced top, chocolate butter cream and cake fallout) or their Chaulkit’ Birthday Cake (chocolate cake with vanilla butter cream, completely covered with sprinkles). Check out their East Aurora shop to browse the favors.
More Info

Dessert Deli Bakery

716 Maple Rd. in Buffalo / (716) 689-2115
Dessert Deli – 6429 Transit Rd. in East Amherst / (716) 204-9531
With pies, cakes, tarts, cheesecakes, brownies, cookies, cupcakes, and individual desserts taking over this menu, you won’t leave empty handed!  The individual desserts are beautifully decorated and very tasty.
More Info

Ohlson’s Bakery & Cafe  

8500 Sheridan Dr. in Buffalo / (716) 626-7783
Ohlson’s is well known for their Wisconsin Kringles made with flaky dough and a dash of cinnamon. Their famous Kringle comes from a family recipe from Wisconsin, where the Kringle was created (hence the name). Their flavors include cheese, apricot, cherry, raspberry, apple cinnamon, caramel pecan, cinnamon and more!
More Info

elm street

Elm Street Bakery / Photo by Jessica Kelly

Elm Street Bakery

72 Elm St. in East Aurora / (716) 652-4720
Elm Street Bakery uses fresh, real ingredients, right down to local farm eggs, freshly squeezed juices, real butter, and more.  Trust them when they say you’ll taste the difference.  All of the pastries in their bakery are made completely from scratch without any mixes or preservatives and their doing some really cute stuff for Valentine’s Day.
More Info

Park Edge Sweet Shoppe

325 Abbott Road in Buffalo / (716) 824-0228
Nothing says “I love you” like a giant cookie bouquet!  These include a combination of sweets like chocolate chip cookies on a stick, assorted cookie packs and all the bells and whistles; aka cool tins, glass mugs, and handmade bows.
More Info

Sweet Pea Bakery

Staub Square, One Buffalo St. in Hamburg / (716) 202-1192
This new Hamburg bakery offers cakes, cookies, pies, and signature items like their Carmelitas (chewy oatmeal, gooey caramel, and dark chocolate layered and baked). Pick up one of their signature items for a unique sweet treat for your valentine.
More Info

Eileen’s Bakery

465 Center Rd. in Buffalo / (716) 674-8586
Eileen’s is offering mini or large pastry hearts in white or pink, along with long stem rose cakes and valentine cookies with pink or red frosting for the holiday. A personal favorite item I’d suggest are their crème horns, also known as Lady Locks which are made with flaky French pastry filled with angel cream and sprinkled with powdered sugar.
More Info
[mc4wp_form id=”103683″]

You might also like…
[justified_image_grid preset=4 row_height=130 height_deviation=1 prettyphoto_social=yes prettyphoto_analytics=yes caption=fixed mobile_caption=same timthumb_crop_zone=t limit=3 hidden_limit=6 max_rows=2 aspect_ratio=16:9 disable_cropping=no recent_posts=yes recents_description=nicetime recents_tags=city-guide post_ids_exclude=current]

Written by <a href="" target="_self">Jessica Kelly</a>

Written by Jessica Kelly

Find More ➭

'Tis The Season

Enter your email to get The Insider Hit List - a timely short list of restaurants, things to do and more recommended by the Step Out Buffalo staff.


Forgotten Password?

You must be logged in to use this feature.