If you haven’t tried dill pickle pizza… you’re missing out. There’s something about the pickle pie that hits differently; conjoining the unique taste of fresh dill with a savory slice of pizza to create the perfect combination of ingredients all in one bite. While its not on every corner like a standard cheese and pep pie, there are a handful of pizza places in Buffalo serving up Pickle Pizza.
Whether you’re a pickle pizza veteran, or just looking to try something new, we’ve got you covered. Just don’t get caught in a pickle trying to choose your spot!
Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!
1. TC Wheelers
341 Wheeler Street Tonawanda, NY 14150 / Website
TC Wheelers in Tonawanda is our first stop on the pickle pizza train. Their signature dill pickle pizza consists of homemade garlic sauce base, sliced dill pickles, mozzarella cheese, and dill seasoning. They recommend topping it off by adding on their toasted everything bagel crust. Woof!
2. Edies Pizza
380 Buffalo Street Hamburg, NY 14075 / Website
Nestled within the Village of Hamburg is Edies Pizza which has been serving up fresh pies to the local community for years. Recently, Edies leveled up their specialty pizza menu by adding ‘pickle pizza’ with ingredients such as garlic oil, dill pickles, basil, and a perfect blend of melted cheeses.
3. The Now Pizzeria
88 Main Street Hamburg, NY 14075 / Website
For over 50 years, The Now has satisfied the taste buds of locals with their delicious pizzas. Their pickle pizza looks very appetizing to say the least. Olive oil, garlic sauce, with dill pickles and mozzarella cheese, are the magic combination of ingredients which make this pickle pizza complete.
4. Carbone’s Pizza
- 568 South Park Ave Buffalo, NY 14204 / 716-855-1749 / Website
- 1126 E. Lovejoy St. Buffalo, NY 14206 / 716-897-5098 / Website
Carbone’s was started in 1978 by Dominic and Carrie Carbone after they saved to buy a spot on South Park and remodeled for 2 years on nights and weekends. Today, Carbone’s distinguishes themselves with several gourmet pizzas including Taco Pizza, Super Steak Pizza, and Cheeseburger Pizza to name a few – one of which is their Pickle Pizza, made with oil, garlic, pickle, mozzarella & monterey jack cheese and parsley. Yum!
5. The Wurlitzer Pizza Co.
1401 Nash Road North Tonawanda, NY 14120 / Website
Wurlitzer Pizza Co. is a northtowns favorite that features their own Dill Pickle Pizza. Consisting of savory ingredients such as: Olive oil, garlic base, dill pickles, oregano, dill, and vegan mozzarella. If you’re a pickle pizza aficionado your next destination should certainly be The Wurlitzer Pizza Co.!
- 3720 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14224 / Website
- 6824 Erie Rd, Derby, NY 14047 / Website
- 242 Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052 / Website
Pasquales Pickle Pizza is made with 100% olive oil, fresh garlic, basil, mozzarella and Romano cheeses, dill pickles, pepper and oregano.
7. Macy’s Place
3348 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14225 / Website
The Pickle Pizza is made consists of fresh dough topped with garlic butter, pickles, seasonings, and their own cheese blend. Choose between small or large/half sheet options.
8. Say Cheese Pizza Company & The Comic Book Café
1771 Love Rd #2, Grand Island, NY 14072 / Website
A comic book cafe has ought to have some unique pizzas right? Well, Say Cheese is bringing it with a Pickle Pizza.
9. John & Mary’s -Hamburg
40 Buffalo St, Hamburg, NY 14075 / Website
John & Mary’s Pickle Pizza is made with a garlic oil base, special seasoning, a blend of cheeses, and dill pickles.
10. Route 78 Street Bar
6036 Transit Road, Depew, NY 14043 / Website
Under their specialty pizzas you’ll find the Dill Pickle Pizza which includes olive oil, garlic, salt and pepper with their homemade dill sauce, dill pickles, and mozzarella cheese.
11. Pizza Amore
2024 Grand Island Blvd, Grand Island, NY 14072 / Website
Pizza Amore is not messing around. The Big Dill consists of Ranch Base Dressing, Dill Pickles, Lite Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, topped with Bread crumbs and Ranch Dressing.